Judge shopping scheme backfires on anti-abortion activists with 'embarrassing' case in Supreme Court

Judge Katangi Brown Jackson, for her part, didn't agree with any of this and suggested that the remedy here to get rid of Mistone for everyone was ridiculously broad, especially given the highly unlikely and so far entirely hypothetical harm that could be done. cause this group of seven doctors. and dentists advice, can I ask her about the remedy in the same way she was talking to the SG? I mean, it makes a lot of sense for individual doctors to apply for a waiver, but as I understand it, they already have that um and so what? What they are asking here is that to prevent them from possibly having to perform these types of procedures, everyone else must be prevented from having access to this medication, so why is that clearly not within Brad's purview?

Resolving the ending of this

case

from that question we finally got Miss Holly's central argument as to why national restrictions should be imposed to protect these seven doctors. These are emergency situations. The doctors surveyed don't necessarily know until they walk into that operating room whether or not this may or may not be a drug-harming

abortion

because these are emergency situations where they can't waste Precious Moments scrubbing no, no, what I'm saying is we assume that We have a world where they can actually object to you saying that. You have my question: Isn't that enough to remedy your problem?

Do we also have to consider your argument that no one else in the world can have this drug or no one else in the United States should have this drug to protect your customers? so again, your honor, it is not possible given the emergency nature of the situation. The advice, allow me, allow me to interrupt. Sorry, that was an actual argument before the

supreme

court

today that the myth that someone has to be banned for everyone after 7 weeks of pregnancy. Because emergency room doctors don't have time to wash their hands repeatedly, we'll have to wait until June to find out what the

court

thinks of that.

Jessica, yeah, scrubbing and scrubbing is too much for the doctors, so no prison for anyone, I mean. I found it horrifying but also shocking, if that can be possible. You know, I hardly found it shocking or surprising because the group of doctors they brought forward with this

case

is an atrocious radical group of anti-

abortion

extremists this is largely who they are they don't care about the patients they don't care about women's health this is a group one of the doctors who have been involved in this case this is a group that wants doctors to be forced to perform cesarean sections instead of abortions on women with life-threatening pregnancies, that's how radical they are and I really don't want that to be lost in this conversation that these doctors are not ordinary this is not good faith side of a political debate, yes, I wonder, Carrie, when you heard the I'll call it skepticism on the part of some conservative

judge

s, do you feel like in this case?

And I'm just going to narrow it down to this one because We'll talk about the bigger picture of reproductive freedom in a second, but do you feel like Josh Holly Aaron Holly? I shouldn't say Josh Holly Josh Holly Aaron Holly's husband, huh, but Aaron Holly is bringing a case that's going anywhere with this court. It does not seem that it seems that the court was willing to dismiss the case because of its standing. The standing is very weak but not only the standing. The facts are weak. The science is weak. The law is weak. This case is weak across the board.

It is absurd that it is even before. The Supreme Court's mistake, as you said, is that Tylenol is so sure that it should be over the counter; It's been highly restricted simply because the anti-abortion movement has been pushing from the beginning to restrict access to prevent people from being able to access the medication so that you know, I hope the court throws it out, but the anti-abortion movement is not going to give up, They will return to project 2025. He has promised that if a Republican president takes office, he will order the FDA to remove my stone from marketing or at least restrict abortion by telemedicine, which has been a key way in which more people have accessed abortion , so they will not give up even if the court dismisses this case.

Dalia, why did the court take this case? post two damage control I mean, what was the point of this was just to give Clarence Thomas what he wants, which is absurd hearings on any kind of social issues, not exactly, the court has a structural problem and the structural problem is that anyone who wanted to file this case could go to Amarillo Texas where Judge Matthew Kmar is like putting, you know, your quarter in the candy bar machine, the only

judge

you were going to find in Amarillo was Judge Karic and then they found out that after they caught him he would do something incredibly dumb like file a nationwide court order that makes it impossible for anyone in the country to get this drug, so we have a Forum Shopping, a judge search problem in this country that I should point out that the courts are trying to address now, if not for At the moment the court has the problem of a dishonest judge, a dishonest Fifth Circuit who blessed large portions of his irrational and indefensible logic and the court had no more There is no choice but to take this case, so I think that as long as we have judges who are like this, we are leading the way to marginal judges who make Samuel Alo and Clarence Thomas look like moderate centrists like they did today, those cases are going to shake up the court and the court is going to be embarrassed. and they embarrassed themselves today and they I'm going to have to take them and throw them out, so that's just a problem with buying judges, it's a problem with false facts and, like Carrie said, bad science that somehow finds its way into the lap from the Court and then the court has to clean it up.

Hello everyone, MSNBC has a new and improved app. You will receive alerts and analysis in real time. Live blogging. In-depth essays. Featured videos and the best coverage of the 2024 election. Download the new MSNBC app. Here we explain how to do it. Tap the App Store on your phone you press search in the bottom right corner you type MSNBC you click on the MSNBC app you click get or the cloud icon and enjoy it