60 Mind-Blowing Harry Potter Plot Holes (MEGA COMPILATION)

Hello everyone, welcome to a special installment of Harry Potter Theory, today we're going back and taking a look at 60 Harry Potter

plot

holes

discussed on the channel over the last few years. I've removed some for a total of 60, so please be aware of some inconsistent numbering. I've also done my best to level out the audio in the videos, but in some cases there is a bit of variation without further ado, let's delve into Colton Smith's thoughtful number one at the end of the fourth book, why didn't Harry put his memory of Voldemort's return in the pensive and then showed it to Fudge and other Ministry people who would have solved almost all the problems of the fifth book with 18800 approval, this

plot

hole? support from many other fans and for good reason, I mean why didn't Harry do this?

He could have easily proven his innocence while also proving that Voldemort had returned. Some of you responded to this comment with a possible answer to the plot hole. i.e. since memories can be altered, Fudge may have accused Harry of simply changing the memory to match his story, however this is quite difficult magic and as we know Harry wasn't actually the strongest when it came to these types of spells. at least not at this stage of the series, remember at this point he hadn't even started his oceny lessons with Professor Snape in which he doesn't immediately excel.

Some other fans mentioned that perhaps Fudge may have accused Dumbledore of tampering with Harry's memory from Fudge. He had already concluded that Harry and Dumbledore were in cahoots, although that may be true. I still think this is an excellent plot hole theory that's worthy of debate. 2. Petunia's magical knowledge from another guy, it is stated at the beginning of book 2 that all the dley did not. I didn't know that Harry wasn't allowed to use magic outside of school because he was underage, at least until the letter started arriving telling them how Petunia didn't know that underage wizards and witches weren't allowed. use magic outside of school when she I grew up around Lily.

I love this plot hole theory and to be completely honest, I had never thought about it, but of course B. Junia should have known. Some other fans responded to this comment with the idea that perhaps Petunia had such a theory. denial complex about Lily's magic that blocked out everything having to do with the Wizarding World, but you'd think that when it was right under her nose in her own home, something would have resonated and brought back these repressed memories from her childhood. In relation to Lily I mean when she was a child Petunia went so far as to send a letter to Dumbledore requesting that she be admitted to the magical school despite her lack of being a good witch that is to say that she was so aware of how magic works The School of Magic and Sorcery worked because she knew how to contact the Director and the Chamber of Secrets of Petros cosmos.

One part I always considered a huge plot hole is that Howry discovered the entrance to the Chamber of Secrets, but Dumbledore couldn't. Harry found out. that Myrtle was the girl who died 50 years ago and he asked how you died, but Dumbledore was there 50 years ago and he knew that Myrtle was the girl who died, so why when he opened the chamber again didn't he immediately go to Myrtle ? and ask him all about her death, it seems quite strange that a wizard like Dumbledore couldn't figure this out, of course he couldn't open the chamber, but he would still know where the entrance was.

This is another huge plot hole in my Dumbledore opinion, shouldn't he have known to ask Myrtle? There is always a theory that he knew or knew that he could ask Myrtle but he was preparing Harry to one day face Voldemort. Personally, he would hate to think this was true, but of course, it is. would make sense because the very idea that Dumbledore wouldn't have thought to ask Myrtle simply doesn't match up with Four Errors in Joe Jackson's Marauder's Map. I noticed another plot hole in the third book when Lupine finds Sirius, Harry, Ron and Herion at the Screaming Shack, he claims that he knew they were there because he saw them on the Marauders' map.

Surely if this were the case, he would have seen two versions of Harry and Amione, as they had gone back in time and were surely only 30 or 40 feet behind them. Lupine would have been quite confused. This theory raises an excellent point. The only reasoning I can think of to explain it is that the Marauders' map doesn't seem to be a terribly honest magic item - for example, apparently the guy from the anime can only be seen on the map in his animal form, if the viewer knew that that wichual wizard was a type of anime, in other words, he would lie to the viewer.

This explains why only Lupine was able to see Peter Pigar on the map when he was in the form of Ron's pet, Scabbers. so maybe the future selves wouldn't show up on the map either unless the viewer knew to look for them there number five the problems with sirius by shenidi prash sirius just creates a lot of problems a beginning of the philosopher's stone dumbledore doesn't ask any questions when he gets hacked He says he borrowed Sirus's bike even though Sirius was presumed to have betrayed the two Potter owls. He was found in serious condition when he was on the run, so why couldn't Ministry Three? he entered and where he went I really have nothing to say about these plot

holes

other than I think they are very brilliant and incredibly accurate six the Hogwarts Express by Darren Thorp also the Hogwarts Express really only goes from King's Cross to Hogs I non-stop if we take Neville for example who is clearly from Yorkshire in the films, at least that's roughly halfway between London and Scotland, why does he have to go to London to catch a train back past Yorkshire and get to Hogwarts and what happens with Cho?

Do Chang and Oliver Wood really have to go from Scotland to London and back to Scotland? We definitely see Cho do this in the movies. Why is everything so focused on London? This is a fantastic logistical plot hole. Do all students coming from the north of the UK have to travel to London and then travel back north to Hogwarts Castle in Scotland, this seems completely illogical, especially for a world full of magic. Hagrid's seven werewolves, Eden's Cubs, are my favorite plot. I think it's the second book where someone says Hagrid. When he was a student he raised werewolf pups under his bed, so he literally had human babies living under his bed for every night except one a month, where they would transform.

LOL WTF this is just funny. I see it less as a plot hole and more as just. a giant oversight, but no matter how you look at it, it's certainly a mistake, clearly the intention here was for Hagrid to have kept magical creatures under his bed, not human babies, eight, Charlie's Wand, by Robin J, 1939, the Plot hole I always remember is Ron's wand. It was actually Charlie's old wand. WS are not items that people can pass on, like when a younger brother can wear his older brothers' hand-me-downs. Charlie should still need his wand for several things, so giving it away only makes his life harder.

Such an interesting plot hole to me because of course I always assumed Ron got Charlie's old wand since the Weasley family didn't have that much money to go around, but if Ron got Charlie's wand Charlie would have needed a new one wand and as Robin J. 1939 says WS are not meant to be passed down from generation to generation, in fact they have been known to rebel and not work properly for witches or wizards they originally did not match, so Charlie does not he had nothing, which we know wasn't the case, or a new wand. was bought for him why not keep the wand meant for him and buy Ron his own it's not like it's worn out like a pair of old shoes very strange in fact nine snape's potions textbook by monteo why Snape donated his old potions book to the school to borrow doesn't seem like the generous type, especially with the zone notes throughout this plot hole theory.

Can I laugh? No, Snape doesn't seem like the generous type. Do you have any answers to this theory? However, he mentioned that perhaps he had left it on purpose to help Harry progress in class and ultimately improve his magical abilities as he got closer and closer to facing Voldemort - after all, in a moment when the Half-Blood Prince recognizes that Harry is using the textbook he once owned. for him and not only does he not take it away but he also does not punish him for cheating. 10 Voldemort's visit to the ministry by Sav G. One thing that always gets me is that in the fifth book Voldemort spends the entire year luring Harry to the Department of Mysteries to get the prophecy because he doesn't want to risk coming himself to the ministry for fear of being exposed, but still shows up anyway when Harry is there and ends up revealing himself.

This plot hole is so on point that I really don't believe it. Is there any explanation that could resolve this at least in my opinion why Voldemort didn't have his mortals make the Unbreakable Vow The Unbreakable Vow is a magical contract made between two parties that uses a binding spell It is a dangerous and powerful spell that carries significant risks essentially if either party breaks The Vow's term, they die instantly and given how honest the spell keeps everyone, it's surprisingly underused in the Harry Potter series and one use case in particular that often jumps to the forefront. in the

mind

s of fans is why not. t Voldemort uses it in his death heaters they were his followers his minions can't think of a better way to keep his followers loyal than the imminent threat of death There are a few possible explanations for this apparent plot hole, but I still think that the vote would have been a better course of action the first possibility is that Voldemort valued fear over loyalty Voldemort was known for instilling fear and his followers instead of trusting in his genuine loyalty, he may have believed that the threat of punishment or death was enough to maintain them. his online followers and that the unbreakable vote was unnecessary.

He also had an extremely large ego which may have made him believe that no one could cross him. He was also extremely powerful and perhaps too confident in his magical abilities. It is possible that he believed that he could control his followers using legitimacy or other similar means and, therefore, he did not feel the need to resort to the unbreakable vote. The Unbreakable Vow would have prevented people like Snape from becoming double agents. Why didn't anyone notice Peter Pettigru on the Marauders map, one of the largest? The plot holes in the Harry Potter franchise revolve around Ron's pet rat Scabbers, later revealed to be Peter Pettigru.

Ron slept with scabbers every night and carried him, which should have been visible on the map of muders that Fred and George Weasley owned, however, the twins never did. he mentioned to anyone that ROM is sleeping with a man named Peter; Some argue that Fred and George may not have noticed all the names on the map, but given their mischievous nature and love of pranks, it seems likely that they would have checked Ron's location enough times to spot their invisible friend Peter. making this particular Revelation a glaring inconsistency in history. I'm sure the name Peter Petre wouldn't have meant much to Fred and George, but the constant proximity to his brother should have set off alarm bells.

Bells, why even have locks? In the Harry Potter story, our protagonists encounter door locks on a few occasions, and while this may seem like a fairly innocuous detail to delve into, I can't help but think about how useless locks are in the wizarding world, The main reason for this is that the Alohamora unlocking spell is taught to Hogwart's first students. If almost every witch and wizard walking around has the ability to unlock locks, it makes them seem very useless. There also seemed to be a variety of door unlocking spells present in the Wizarding World which makes this doubly confusing.

Goen cevy is using muggle technology at Hogwarts in the Goblet of Fire. It is established that Muckle technology does not work at Hogwarts, preventing students from using phones or email to communicate with their parents, however, taking that information into account. It seems baffling that Colin Cy's Muckle camera seems to work just fine. A teacher may have enchanted the camera to make Colin feel more at home and allow him to capture his magical experiences, but I'm a little skeptical about how Fred and George got there. The Marauders' Map The Marauders' Map was originally created by James Potter Sirius BlackRemis Lupine and Peter Pettigru during their time at Hogwarts and since the map's creation it has changed hands on a few occasions when Fred and George Weasley began attending Hogwarts, from where they stole the map.

Argus filch and after using it extensively they passed it to Harry Potter as they handed him the map, they inform him that the password to activate it is I solemnly swear that I am up to no good by touching the map with a wand and reciting the password, the map reveals its secrets, including the layout of Hogwart School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, the location of each person within the castle, and secret passageways that can be used to navigate the school grounds undetected, the problem here is how Fred would have discovered it and George. There is no identifiable explanation for how the pair would have revealed the map's secrets or even why it would have stood out as an item of interest.

The trail is inconsistent after first setting foot in the World of Magic. Harry was repeatedly warned against using magic outside of school premises and performing muggles. The concealment of the magical world depended on this. The Ministry of Magic attempted to instill discipline in young wizards and witches by tracking any use of magic in their vicinity using a tracking spell, however, throughout the series, this method of application was shown to be highly inconsistent, e.g. When Dobby or Harry performed magic on the dley, the Ministry was quickly informed. In contrast, when members of the Order of the Phoenix used magic on the same location, there seemed to be no reaction from them.

Ultimately, the tracking spell proved highly effective. ineffective, particularly because he was not able to properly identify the person responsible for casting the Magic in the first place. Why didn't Harry contact Sirius instead of going to the ministry throughout the Harry Potter series? His godfather Sirius communicates through a variety of covert means, but when Harry becomes concerned that Sirus is in danger, he employs none of them in the Order of the Phoenix. Harry has a vision of Sirius being held captive at the Ministry and fearing that his friend is in danger, he recklessly rushes to his aid, as a result, Harry falls into the clutches of the Death Eaters and Sirius ultimately loses his life;

However, he feels that this entire tragedy could have been avoided if Harry had simply used an alternative, already established method of communication. As you see earlier in the series, Sirius had given Harry a two-way mirror that she and Harry's father, James, used during their school days, while Harry uses a fragment of the mirror to contact Abba later in the series. series, it would have been more advantageous if he had used it to confirm whether Sirius was in danger or not before acting on his fears. The books mention that Harry forgot the mirror in his haste, but it seems highly unlikely that anyone would have thought to use it at any time.

Age is mcgonagal, this particular plot hole actually branches into the Fantastic Beast universe according to the timeline presented in the books. It was a common belief that Professor McGonagal was born in the year 1935, however, her appearance in a scene set at Hogwarts in 1910 depicting the crimes of Grindlewald left everyone a little confused. Mle's presumed year of birth places her in the late of the 1880s, but her engagement at the age of 18 to a Muggle who died in the first Wizarding War seems to defy this estimate for no reasonable reason at present. explanation for this inconsistency Sirius and the polyjuice potion, although Sirius Black was able to clear his name in the eyes of those closest to him, he remained unable to prove his innocence to The Wider Wizarding World, so he was confined to Grimel Place , largely unable to join the group. other wizards in the ord's battle against Voldemort on occasion his frustration led him to break the rules of his confinement by transforming into his dog form to visit Harry and escape the confines of the house, however Sirius was cautious as the ministry he was aware of his dog form. and he needed to avoid being sent back to aaban and while transforming into his dog form was certainly a sensible precaution, there is another method that Sirius could have explored that seems more appropriate: the polyjuice potion.

The polyjuice potion that allows you to change your physical form. seemingly not too complex to create, even students with minimal training seem to be able to handle it and have the ability to fool any other magician quite easily. Sirius could have assumed the physical form of another member of the order traveling largely unnoticed, why wouldn't Sirius have explored. this option is a mystery to me Harry and the thestrals a thestral is a breed of winged horse with skeletal features and representative of Ian that resembles a kind of evil Pegasus, these horses, if they can be called, that pull carriages at Hogwarts and are only visible to those who have witnessed the death.

Harry sees these creatures for the first time at the beginning of his fourth year after the death of Cedric Digory. However, fans have pointed out that Harry should have seen the thestrals earlier in Goet of Fire after the tournament ends and Digory has already died. Harry sees the horseless carriages, theoretically he should have been able to see the thestrals at that point, but they only become visible to him in the next book. JK Rolling has addressed this discrepancy by explaining that a person must fully internalize death in order to see the thestrals at all. He told me that Harry saw people die before he could see the thestrals just to clear this up once and for all this wasn't a mistake I really thought this through Harry didn't see his parents die he was one year old and in a crib in that moment although you never see that scene I wrote it and then I cut it he didn't see it he was too young to appreciate it when you find out about thestrals you discover that you can see them only when you really understand death in a broader sense, when you really know what it means, Someone said that Harry saw Quirrel die, but that's not true.

He was unconscious when Quirrel died in the Philosopher's Stone. He didn't know until he regained consciousness. That Quirrel had died when Voldemort left his body. you have Cedric with Cedric Fair Point Harry had just watched Cedric die when he returned to the carriages to return to the Hogs station. I thought about that at the end of the cup because I knew from the beginning what he was attracting the attention of. Chamber of Secrets in which there are chariots pulled by invisible things. I knew what was there. I decided it would be something strange. By the end of the book, anyone who has been grieved knows that there is such a thing as immediate shock, but it takes a little time to fully appreciate that you will never see that person again until that happens.

I didn't think Harry could see the thestrals, which means when he comes back he saw these creepy things, that set the tone for Phoenix which is a much darker book Neville and the Madmen another plot hole related to Harry's memories of His past emerges when the madmen appear on the Hogwarts train. While most of the children feel cold and miserable in his presence, Harry experiences a more intense reaction, hears someone screaming, collapses, and requires Professor Lupine's help to chase him away. to the dementor. It is explained that Harry is deeply affected because he has witnessed true horrors in his past and the screams he hears are a re

mind

er of the death of his mother.

This explanation is logical but it begs the question why Neville. who also experienced a tragic event in childhood did not have a similar reaction on the train. Neville's parents were tortured to insanity by the cruciatus curse when he was only 16 months old, which is almost the same age Harry was when his parents died. Furthermore, Neville even visited his parents in St to witness their condition and gain knowledge of what happened to them, one would assume that this level of horror would be enough to affect Neville in the presence of the Dementors, as well as the Port Key timeline. during the Quiddit World Cup Harry and the Weasleys. use a port key an old boot to reach the event Throughout the wizarding world numerous port keys are set which involve specific activation times, however the port key that Voldemort uses to transport Harry in the tri was a tournament it must have been enchanted to function only within the maze Since Voldemort could not know when Harry would reach the cup, the question arises as to how the relocation key was programmed correctly.

Some port keys may have larger timing windows, but the World Cup port keys had a small window to prevent muggles from using them. tri wiard cups The port key probably had a wider window to cover the contestants' time in the Labyrinth. My point is that the details behind the port keys and their timing remain a mystery why the ministry didn't use their truth serum, verita serum capable of The Drinker's compelling truth is one of the most powerful potions in the world. of writing, but for some strange reason it is very underused in the story. This potion had the potential to greatly benefit the Ministry of Magic by solving a multitude of problems more efficiently, for example following the First Away War, this truth serum could have been used during the trials of known Death Eaters, some escaped. from prison claiming to be under the imperious curse, while others like Sirius Black were wrongfully convicted, the use of the veritus serum could have removed any doubt.

I'm not going to go much further, as I've actually already done a much more extensive breakdown of why the veritus serum was used so infrequently, but if you're curious, go check out why Sirius Escape didn't appear in Harry sooner. Potter and the Prisoner of Aaban Harry learns that a dangerous assassin, Sirius Black, has escaped from Aaban Prison with the intention of killing him, although Sirius' motivations become clearer towards the film's climax. One thing is not clear why he decided to remain imprisoned for so long. The movies and books know that Sirius used his animus of a large black dog to escape.

He intentionally lost weight, then transformed and slipped through the prison bars. However, this raises the question of why he didn't do it sooner when he transformed into his animal form. It seems relatively simple, Sirus could have easily lost weight in a matter of weeks, so why did he rot and aaban for years? One argument for why Sirius would have remained at Aaban is that, however, he would have had no way of proving his innocence after seeing Pettigru in the Weasley family photo in the newspaper. He would have seen this as an opportunity to regain his freedom and prove his innocence, prompting his escape.

Why was Cho Chang at the Battle of Hogwarts in Goblet of Fire? We are introduced to Cho Chang, a fifth year student. student who becomes involved with Cedric Digory and later joins Dumbledore's Army, he also develops a romantic relationship with Harry, interestingly despite graduating from Hogwarts in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood. Prince Joe is still present at the school during the Battle of Hogwarts, this raises the question of why she is still there, especially since she is seen wearing a uniform, the answer to this plot hole comes down to which version of Harry Potter you are watching, book or movie in the books.

Joe returns to Hogwarts after receiving a message in the Dumbledore's Army coin subsequently appeared in Hog's head and entered Hogwarts through Ariana's portrait to join the fight in the films. On the other hand, Joe Chang is depicted as if he was in the same year as Harry, so he would have been present at the battle last year. financial system Magic money does it make any sense? Really I do not think so. Now let me start by saying that just because the wizard type is much more independent than the muggles and is able to achieve all sorts of things through magic, doesn't mean that their society can operate without a financial system, currency certainly exists in the Wizarding World, existing in the form of chevrons, sickles and canuts, there is even an established magical economy that allows for a medium of exchange with goods and services, so what is the problem here?

The problem is that there is apparently no consistency regarding what things cost or where this money actually comes from. In Harry Potter there are several established bodies, including the Hogwarts ministry of magic and even a hospital in a traditional economy, these things They are paid for through taxes, etc., what I wonder about is aside. From the fines, how do these organizations obtain the necessary income to maintain their basic infrastructure? The next big problem arises from the inconsistencies: the cost of produce, drinks, and suet cost sickles and canuts, which makes sense, I suppose, but then a Hogwarts textbook can cost as much as nine gallons for a family like The Weasleys, a gallon is a lot, so although they obviously fight, three wands doesn't make much sense to me.Multiple No witch or wizard is complete without their wand and most of the time the wand is the instrument through which they can channel most of their power.

They are made by wand makers like Olivander. They are composed of a unique wand wood and a core that also varies in length and flexibility. In the series we see all kinds of witches and wizards channeling magic through theirs, but one part of the story caught my attention when Harry used several at once, in particular, Harry ends up harnessing several at once to produce more power casting an extra powerful spell against fenri Grayback my problem with this, why doesn't anyone else do it? If more units equals more power, then why doesn't everyone use a pair? There's really no point in five Secret Keeper ERS.

One of the reasons the Potters died was because of their chosen one. The Secret Keeper, her good friend Peter Pettigru, a Secret Keeper, is a witch or wizard appointed to hide a secret secured by Fidelia's charm who hides the secret within the Secret Keeper's Soul. Initially, James and Lily chose Sirius Black, but felt he would be an obvious target for Voldemort. Sirius instead recommended Peter, who we know doesn't do a particularly good job. The secret in question was the location of the Potter cabin. A secret that was linked to Petr's soul. The charm in conjunction with a Secret Keeper essentially becomes absolutely hidden keeping the occupants safe, so the glaringly obvious problem here is that James and Lily could have simply been their own Secret Keepers, they could have hidden safely with their own secret. that would never have been. found but instead they chose one of their friends which is nice but also makes no sense seven unbreakable vows the unbreakable vow is a binding magical contract that connects two parties the purpose is simple it is to bind a companion or magician to a promise the participants stand in front of each other and hold each other's right hands while a third acts as a kind of mediator or witness and places the tip of his wand in the hands of the two participants the mediator acts almost like a minister and will begin to State conditions or responsibilities are related to the vote after setting each condition of the vote, the participant who is asked to fulfill such responsibilities must accept them one by one if he did not fulfill his part of the bargain after this.type of vote You suffer the ultimate consequence, death, this seems like a really good way to ensure that people are on your side, but in the story we don't really see much of this happening.

Snape walks into one with Narcissa swearing to protect Draco, but neither of them. Neither Voldemort nor Dumbledore seem to be using this type of vote to ensure that their allied followers are on their side. You would think that an unbreakable vow would be part of the Death Eater initiation process, but that is not the case. There is a lot of deception in it. The story of Harry Potter, which could have been made clearer with a simple vote, eight portraits were introduced early in the story in the Hogwarts Wizarding Portraits depicting witches and wizards from all eras.

It is reinforced that the living portraits in The Wizarding World are mere traces. of the dead person capable only of imitating his basic personality traits has no feelings, memories or any special abilities as we can see with the ghost, everything is fine, however, this explanation of the portraits is broken when the portrait of Dumbledore is able of communicating wisdom to Snape, honestly, ancient portraits are certainly an area of ​​the story where some clarification is needed. nine the Elder Wand ah the Elder Wand one of the main drivers behind history and the most powerful wand in all of existence.

The Elders are responsible for an incredible amount of death in history, an enigmatic artifact made even more enigmatic due to their unusual passing of ownership. In order to truly master the wand, you must become its true master, but this is where things come. They get complicated, the W supposedly only changes owners when its master has actually been surpassed by another and it is generally implied that this is achieved through murder; However, there are several exceptions to this rule, such as when Grindlewald stunned Gregorovich Malfoy by disarming Dumbledore and Harry finally disarming Malfoy. The problem with this whole disarming thing is that the wand is reinforced as this relentless power-hungry object that wants to be paired with the most powerful wizard in existence.

If that's the case, then how can a much weaker wizard like Malfoy become master of it simply by disarming the extremely powerful Dumbledore? The whole loyalty thing is a bit of a disaster among the International Wizarding Community, perhaps the biggest plot hole of all for me is that in a Wizarding World the emphasis on the world meaning the UK and every other place on the planet Voldemort only seems to be a threat to Britain Voldemort was an incredibly powerful dark wizard and if he really came to power he would have been a threat to everyone, not just Britain, so my question is why didn't other magical communities help, for which other European countries did not help, it is simply not the case. makes sense number one the whereabouts of hagrid and

harry

during the missing day at the beginning of the novel, we see alpis dumore meet professor manura mcgonagal on privet drive while they await the arrival of rubius hrid, who has been entrusted to bring a baby Harry Potter a At His Uncle's House, this scene is depicted after dark, as Dumore uses his Outdoor Pusher to collect all the light orbs from the surrounding street lamps to ensure that no neighbors see them.

We also know that a whole day has passed since then. Voldemort murdered Harry's parents and attempted to murder him. We know this because Harry's uncle, Vernon Derley, describes all the strange things he sees that day on his way to and during work. These weird things are, of course, The Wizarding World's celebrations in response to Voldemort's decision. feat, this means that an entire day has passed from the previous night when Hagrid drove Harry from the crime scene to the couple's arrival at number four Privet Drive, leaving the very obvious question of where the hell they were for 24 hours, Now we know that Hrid borrowed the black Sirus flying motorcycle, but it clearly wouldn't have taken him a whole day to ride a magical flying motorcycle, right?

We know he blew up the bike at least part of the way because when he arrives, his arrival is from the air, so the math just doesn't add up in this case, it's definitely a whole plot, two baby Harrys left out of the derley in my opinion. . Do we really want to believe that the three magical beings, Dumbledore McGonagal and Hagrid, who claim to care deeply about the recently orphaned? One-year-old Harry has just been left outside the dery gates in the middle of a cold October night. Think about it, there is no mention of any sort of magical spell cast to protect little Harry from The Elements nor do the three Wizards seem so bothered by the idea that they would simply leave a baby on his mother's doorstep with the assumption that sometime the next day Vernon or Patun will find him, if it's not a plot hole, it's at least incredibly strange.

Number three, Mrs. Weasley doesn't remember. Platform 9 and 3/4, this plot hole is more like a giant oversight, in my opinion, Philosopher's Stone readers may remember that the only reason Harry notices the Weasley family while he is in King's Cross station is because he overhears Ron's dear mum, Molly, trying to remember the platform number of the Hogwarts Express out loud. I must add that I personally find it incredibly difficult to believe that having previously taken five Weasley children to Platform 99 and 3/4 throughout her Hogwarts education, she would not have this number at all. cemented in his mind without mentioning that the platform number never changes each subsequent year that Harry takes the train to school the platform is always 9 and 3/4 the number four the concept of poor witches and wizards the concept that members of the Wizarding Community could be poor is quite confusing if you ask me, of course this idea is presented to us clearly in the Philosopher's Stone with the explanation of the Weasleys' reputation and the description of Ron's shabby clothes and he hands me the wand , but in a world where magic can conjure food and transform one inanimate object into another, couldn't any witch or wizard who wanted to be better off simply create more wealth for themselves?

It seems to me that this is a pretty substantial plot hole number five about how the Dys got back from the island when you probably remember when Harry started receiving admission letters from him to Hogwarts. Vernon Dley took the whole family to a rickety old cabin on an isolated island in a desperate attempt to hide from the magic cards. This didn't work, of course, as Hagrid was in charge of making sure that Harry actually received the acceptance letter from him, located them easily, and delivered Harry's mail in person. Now the plot hole in this part of the story is that the island was so isolated that the only way the Deries and Harry could get there.

It was traveling in a small rowboat, as Dumbledore granted Hagrid permission to use magic until he found Harry. He flew to the island himself, presumably using his umbrella, which he illegally built using his broken wand, but anyway I digress to find out where Harry Hagrid was. They were no longer allowed to use magic, so the two left the island using the only rowboat, so how the hell did the Durleys get back to the mainland? The six traps for the stone were solved by untrained children now near the beginning of the novel The Philosopher's Stone is transferred from the grottoes to Hogwarts by Hagrid on Dumbledore's orders.

Presumably this is done to keep the stone in the safest place possible, however, why would Dumbledore believe that a castle full of a group of curious students would be a safer place? that a magical bank vault that trapped any intrusion for eternity with goblins only checking the Vault every decade or two is beyond my comprehension; In any case, we later learn that the stone is placed behind traps and enchantments created by all the combined magical abilities the Hogwarts professor had to offer, which brings me to a plot hole within this plot hole. the plot, why would the traps protecting this incredibly valuable magical artifact have a solution?

Each trap is actually more of a puzzle, but once again I digress anyway, not only were each of the traps the stones solvable, they were all solvable by a group of top students, not the best and brightest. wizards, but three 11 year olds, two of whom did not have it even though magic existed less than a year before, number seven Hogwarts does not offer basic muggle subjects now it is arguable that perhaps witches and wizards do not have a lot of use for maths or muggle history, but the fact that there are no language classes is a bit disconcerting to me, firstly, you would think there would be even less of a focus on being able to write and communicate properly, but there would also be I thought that the language of other countries, not to mention other magical species, would have been offered as at least eight electives, the required school supplies are archaic, okay, this has never made any sense to me, I mean, I understand that magic to It's often associated with medieval times and all, but why on earth wouldn't one of the most prominent magical schools in the world have evolved with modern times in terms of school supplies?

I mean, maybe with some witches and wizards who live more than a century a year. It's possible that some of these items just haven't been removed yet, as I could see that some of the older teachers weren't updating the list of what is required for their classes, but do you think that the teenagers who make up the majority of the population of Hogwarts would have at least requested the option of getting a pack of pens in a notebook instead of quills and parchment nine the hypocritical punishment for violating curfew as you may remember halfway through Philosopher's Stone Harry is caught violating curfew a curfew that has been put in place to protect the students of Hogwarts and yet the punishment given to children for going out after dark is to send them into the darkness and not just any darkness, but the darkness within the Forbidden Forest. , full of dangerous and creepy magical creatures, so strange. 10 Dumbledore destroying the stone at the end, so when Dumbledore explains to Harry at the end of the novel that the stone has simply been destroyed, a very obvious question arose, wait, it didn't stick in my mind, why go to all that trouble to protect the stone and transfer it from the caves? to Hogwarts only to end up destroying it if getting rid of it was the safest option, shouldn't it have been the first option?

WannaI mean, I'm all for trying something to see if it works, but this seems incredibly risky. Which I did, I guess there's the argument that he also suspected Voldemort was gaining strength and thought this might be a good way to gas him or something or maybe he just wanted to see what Harry Potter was capable of since he admits at the end. installment of the series in which he has been advising him to face his death against Voldemort or maybe this is just another plot hole without a rational explanation eight you don't need glasses with poli juu the poli juu potion is one of those classic concoctions that They seem to open up a lot of little plot holes and when we look at how the magic potion was used in the Chamber of Secrets, this trend continues at one point, Harry and Ron take a drink of polyjuice and transform into crab copies. and but there is a slight inconsistency with the whole scene when Harry transforms, he forgets to take off his glasses, which doesn't really make sense since it has long been established that eyesight is one of the traits that transforms after consume a polyjuice potion, then Harry should have done so. iMed immediately noted that he didn't need his glasses unless Mal, lack thereof, also suffered from poor vision and simply never wore glasses because they were too vain and didn't want Draco to make fun of them.

Harry lied to Hedwig long before Harry had any. Suspecting that a basilisk lived in the Hogwarts dungeons, he was busy suffering during the summer months among the Muggles. At one point, while sitting next to Hedwig, the owl seemed to gesture toward Harry almost as if she were asking to be released from her cage, so she was able to enjoy a quick flight, but Harry didn't open the small cage door. his cage, but he simply told Hedwick that he was not allowed to use magic outside of Hogwarts, but if you think about it, why would Harry need to use magic in To open his cage, all he needed was a small key that was clearly visible, or Harry lied because he didn't want to deal with taking his pet flying or something else was six feet tall, how did a nearly decapitated Nick recover every time a poor guy? helpless victim stared into the eyes of a basilisk, they were sure they would die, that's what made the enormous snake such a terrifying beast, but during Harry's second year at Hogwarts, the students and creatures that were struck by The Gaze of the Basilisk was lucky to avoid him directly, he simply saw the eyes of the dark serpent through a reflection that saved them from Death;

Instead, these victims were petrified and trapped in a suspended state, but in addition to these lucky living beings there was an Undead Spirit that met the basilisk's eyes directly towards Nick, almost headless as Nick was already dead. The Gaze of the Basilisk was not able to take him further away from the world of the living, but seemed to petrify him as well. Now those among the living who saw the Basek Gaze had a long and difficult road to recovery and managed to be cured through meticulous witchcraft. from Madam Pomfrey in Hogwart's hospital wing, but those elixirs and remedies must not have had much effect on the ghosts, so how did Nick manage to recover from the attack of one of the deadliest dark creatures in the entire wizarding world?

I'm surprised that it was like that. any effect on him in the first place five why Dobby wanted to save Harry Dobby's courage and the house elves' bulk were among the most endearing parts of the Chamber of Secrets, but have you ever wondered why Dobby did everything possible to save Harry? because if you think of all the ways a person in the house could spend their energy helping a random second-year Hogwart student, it's not one of the best ways. Although Dobby probably heard about Harry Potter when he was eavesdropping. Draco's conversations with his mother, what would have made Dobby so obsessed with the Boy Who Lived and how could Dobby know that Harry was going to be the target of the creature inside the Chamber of Secrets even though Draco's voice Malou thought very little of house elves and Dobby in particular, Luluus was a somewhat discreet wizard, not the type of person to openly discuss a secret plot like the one that saw him surreptitiously slip Tom Riddle's diary into Tom Riddle's things.

Jenny Weasley as Dobby whether she knew about the chamber and why Dobby decided to save Harry are two questions that clearly have no answers, of course there are a few different explanations that could partially fill this plot hole. Dobby obviously knew that the Death Eaters and their leader were even worse than normal wizards when they came into the care of the house elves and if Lord Voldemort successfully overthrew the ministry of magic, then Dobby's life would be much worse, perhaps that was enough for him. that Dobby became obsessed with Harry and tried to save him. She makes sense as much as I love Gilderoy Lockart, his very existence seems to undermine the intelligence of the rest of the magical community.

Harry Ron and Tomione determined pretty easily that Lockheart was a scammer, and I know these three Hogwart students aren't exactly one. Ordinary wizards and witches together have reached greater heights than many adult magic users in The Wizarding World, but it's still strange that these children exposed Lockheart faster than anyone else and, make no mistake, at the beginning of the second school of magic. Harry Potter. The year when Gilderoy Lockhart acted as Britain's bravest wizard was still intact after all, besides Albert Dumbledore, some wizards even suspected that Lockhart's achievements were not his own and even Dumbledore's perspective on the matter did not.

It was fully explained until JK Rowling wrote a separate article. piece that explains why the wise old wizard would have wasted his students' time with such a useless teacher. She's sure some like MRS Snape had doubts about him, but it's quite strange that the rest of the Hogwarts faculty didn't notice Lockart and immediately requested his dismissal. At school perhaps they kept their mouths shut out of respect for Dumbledore, the three Basilisks, Venom, and Harry's hours in the depths of Hogwarts while defending the Basilisk in the Chamber of Secrets, Harry struggled to keep the snake at bay and In the end, when he struck a fatal blow at the snake, Harry himself received a fatal wound, one of the dark creatures' fangs pierced Harry's skin and injected him with the infamous Basilisk Venom.

From that moment on, it would only be a few minutes until Harry met a certain death, of course, against the Phoenix he fought. On Alber's part Dumbledore intervened again and again, his tears healing Harry's wounds before Venom took him to the other side, but that opens up some questions, since we know that the Venom basilisk is one of the only materials capable of destroying HW's crucial points, in fact, when Harry Ron and Hmane tour the British countryside during the Deathly Hallows event, it's almost exclusively basilisk poison and the poison's power was passed on to the Gryffindor sword they use, so That shouldn't the poison have killed the part of Voldemort's soul that had attached itself to Harry?

Eventually, JK Rawling was forced to answer this question, but that answer only seemed to justify the continued existence of the HW crux on a technicality. If you're interested in a full explanation, I made a video about it, two broken ones should work, but Ron's doesn't. Throughout Chamber of Secrets, Ron Weasley stoically faces life at Hogwarts with a broken wand, unfortunately for the youngest Weasley, his wand had been practically destroyed during his flight to Hogwarts earlier in the semester, now Ron could have easily asked them helps his parents. a new one from Olivander's shop, but that would have risked a reprimand and Ron was already too traumatized to take another howl in the Great Hall in front of all his classmates, so Ron simply suffered failure after failure as he struggled to perform the most basic spells, but Ron's experience with a broken wand doesn't compare well to others.

Hagrid used a broken wand after he first broke it when he was expelled from Hogwarts decades earlier. Yes, she was enclosed in an umbrella, but she was still there. broken even though the half-giant suffered some setbacks during spell casting, he was still able to achieve the desired results more or less, which makes you wonder why Ron's wand was so bad, is it just a simple blip or the Ron's wand was built with inferior equipment? Most likely, Ron's own inexperience was the reason why his broken wand worked so poorly. If he had been a more experienced wizard, he would have cast better spells despite the sad state of his basilisk-sized wand at the end of the Chamber of Secrets.

What Harry Potter hears inside the walls was explained to be a basilisk and its voice came not from the walls but from the nooks, crannies and pipes beyond, but if you know anything about interior plumbing then you'll realize That pipes are actually very small, often even of commercial quality. The pipes are only a few centimeters in diameter. Relatively normal, non-exotic snakes have been known to get stuck in commercial pipes and required expensive plumbers to remove them, so how could a basilisk that was larger than many? Of the wingless dragons that populated Hungary fit well in such small spaces, the simple answer is that not even underground pipes could have fit the enormous Beast, so how was it able to navigate Hogwarts and appear where students and cats least Did you expect it?

Like a fantastic kingdom, even the sewage system inside Hogwarts was gigantic and there I say majestic, there were certainly places a short Lisk could have fit in, but the bathroom pipes don't seem like it, why didn't they clean the Chamber of the secrets? The Basilisk is one of the most dangerous creatures in the entire Wizarding World compared to other beasts such as acromantulas and Giants. The Basilisk was actually much worse to show you how dangerous they are. An average wizard would have a better chance of surviving a fight with a Hungarian Horntail than the snake Herpo first created and it makes sense if you think about it, just one look from a basilisk was enough to stop your heart, which meant that you had to fight with your eyes closed how many creatures would be able to exchange blows with a basek if they were robbed of their sight and the giant Serpent's fangs excrete the vilest poison any magical creature could produce so you have to wonder why Alber Dumbledore did not clean up the remains of the Basilisk after Harry Potter. kill him at the end of the Chamber of Secrets his rotting corpse was more than a disgusting display every inch of the bassist was a precious ingredient that any dog ​​wizard or distraught student would love to recover for their potions, can you imagine all the dark hexes? and curses that a single drop of Basilisk Venom could create and let's not forget that the cham of Secrets was created by Salazar syin in the first place, he created the chamber and left the Monstrous basek behind in protest of his other co-founders who had refused. to follow his lead in banning Muggle-born students from attending Hogwarts, why didn't Dumbledore and the rest of the Hogwarts staff enter the chamber and clear it of all the dark relics? of her parents, her poor mother and father, who had never considered the risk their daughter was taking at Hogwarts, would be forced to visit Hogwarts and attend their own daughter's funeral, but there was a problem with the fact that Hogwarts would never allowed muggles to set foot on their campus. which meant Myrtle's parents shouldn't have made the trip, so how did they do it?

Of all the theories on the internet, the most compelling was quite simple, perhaps the headmaster at the time made an exception, of course Tom Riddle attended Hogwarts decades before Albert Dumbledore did. promoted, so the headmaster of the time must have been plowing diid as one of the oldest magicians to hold the title and a particular fan of the rules, it is unlikely that Dipit would have let Myrtle's parents know how he survived the Basilisk and while we're talking about the lower Lisk, have you ever wondered what it ate, since it was supposedly locked inside the chamber for its 10,000 year lifespan?

What could he have eaten to survive so long? As you think about this question, you might be tempted to chime in with some obvious Answers: Typically man-made structures quickly become home to pests like mice and rats, but that would have been enough to sustain the Basilisk. Even during the second year of Harry Potter there were no recorded deaths and no students were eaten and students certainly seem to be the most likely. source of sustenance in the otherwise deserted Castle, an easy way to fill this plot hole is to assume that a large magical rodent-like creature also resided in the Chamber of Losses.Secrets with so much water and debris flowing around them that it would not be unthinkable for nests. of giant rats to call the Chamber their second home but of course herper the creep, the terrifying dark wizard who first successfully raised basilisks, never told us how often and how much they needed to eat for some more developed theories addressing this, watch my longer video on the subject of basilisks hissing we all know that only parceled tongues can communicate with snakes that fact is still true for basilisks 2, that's why Harry Potter was the only one who could hear the faint whispers in the walls during his second year at Hogwarts, but throughout Harry's time at Hogwarts, Ron and Hmane had the opportunity to observe him speaking in Parcel more than a couple of times and during those interactions they were able to hear very clearly not only the strange speech of Potter but also the hissing of the snake, but throughout their second year, when Sister and Ron were near Harry, they seemed oblivious to the large hissing snake that was somewhere nearby climbing up the old leaky pipes behind them. the brick walls.

You might be tempted to quickly sweep this plot hole under the rug by pointing out Harry's telepathic connection. to snakes or you could claim that snakes' hissing seems to be amplified for pack tongues. That could all be true, but it's certainly inconsistent that Ron and Amione sometimes hear the whistle and sometimes hear nothing at all. Some simple math when we look at the plot. holes inside the Chamber of Secrets it's easy to try to sweep them under the rug and find a reason for their existence and I guess that's all part of the fun, for example when we wonder why the Basilisk didn't target Harry instead. more aggressively before.

I find several reasons, namely Voldemort's own vanity, but when it comes to this particular plot hole, I think the truth is that the numbers just don't add up within the Chamber of Secrets. Lord Voldemort made a small mistake by trying to belittle James and Lily. The sacrifice of Potter, the dark wizard, claimed that the death of parents from a young age was 12 years of peace and tranquility for his son, but if Voldemort had studied a little more in math class, he would have realized that only about 11 years had passed since the fateful night. had first tried to kill the Potter boy plot hole or error whatever the case may be this funny little inconsistency is one that opens up a treasure trove of topics for debate eight six Time Turner rules now when we talk about plot holes in aaban's prison By the time the Turners present more than their fair share to begin with, it really doesn't make much sense to allow a 13-year-old girl access to time travel, even if Hmane were the most reliable student in Hogwarts, why would Professor Manura McGonagal trust you?

With such a dangerous device she not only could have destroyed the future, but she could have also hurt herself. Time travel was complicated, as Lord Voldemort and Harry Potter's own children demonstrated decades later, which brings me to my next point: why weren't Time Turners used more frequently? In later years, JK Rowling carefully explained how impractical a time change would be to prevent her loved ones from dying; After all, with time travel established in The Wizarding World, it wouldn't really make sense for people like Dumbledore not to use it, especially when Trav travels. back in time would have saved the world from so many of Voldemort's atrocities during the events of Aaron's Prison every time Turner in Britain had been enchanted with the special spell so that its users could only stay in the past for up to 5 hours. but by the time alus seus Potter enrolled at Hogwarts, the rules by the time Turner changed, a new batch of devices had been created and one of them provided rampant travel to and from the past when we tried to wonder why the Ministry of Magic and Hogwarts staff never use time travel more often, the only obvious answer we can find is that it was simply too dangerous, but that raises another question number five: why didn't Voldemort try to get a time turner?

Why didn't Voldemort ever try to get hold of him? In a Time Turner, even if he had only used the devices controlled by the Ministry of Magic that did not allow free travel through time, the dark wizard could have accomplished much more than he did during the S years that Harry attended Hogwarts and When you think about You have to wonder why Voldemort never tried to create a real Time Turner like the one Draco Malfor used when he saved his son Scorpius and Potter from the past. Voldemort was the most powerful dark wizard in recorded history.

Maybe he even was. Greater than Herper the Filthy, the infamous sorcerer who first spawned basilisks and when he tore his soul into seven pieces and created his walks, Voldemort proved that there was no aspect of magic that was too taboo for him to use, then , if a teenager like Kione was able to achieve so much with the Turners, why did Lord Voldemort never employ them if his dead had only one of the Turners in their possession the night their Master first died? Although they failed to kill a baby Harry Potter, they could have quickly brought him back to life. four Harry used magic at school several times throughout the film series Harry Potter shuddered at the thought of using magic outside of Hogwarts, he was underage and performing magic was always risky business, the ministry quickly tracked him down and Harry was beginning to get the feeling that Cornelius's subordinates were not very happy with his troublesome ways, even when Harry was older, there were times when he was hesitant to use magic outside of school. but during aaban's prisoner

harry

used a small lumos maxima spell while practicing wizardry in his bedroom even though it was a relatively small display of magic and nothing that would risk exposure to muggles the ministry could have punished him and harry should have been good.

Aware of that, but he didn't seem to care as he practiced the incantation under the safety of the sheets. Mrs. Norris's three yellow eyes. Arus Felch was the resident caretaker of Hogwart School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. He was famous for more than a few strange things. personality traits, but the students knew him best for the strange relationship he shared with his pet, Mrs. Norris, the brown cat was more than just a creature that Filch fed and bathed, although Dumbledore treated Argus with respect, there was no debate around the sad fate that filch suffered. He was a squib, the descendant of magical parents who had no magical abilities of his own and because of that, he was never able to climb the rigid hierarchy of the Magical Society instead learning the ins and outs of potion brewing and launching a successful career as an Elixir. for hair loss or a zoologist from MAG VCH only served the magical class and as a caretaker that meant cleaning up the messes that all the young wizards and warlocks around Hogwarts made and Mrs.

Norris, his only companion, was always faithfully at his side. his side, but if you pay attention. Pay attention to Mrs. Norris and the Prisoner of Aban, you will notice that his eye color changes now. Fine's eyes would also change in later films, but in Aaban's Prisoner, if you focus, you can see them flashing yellow in an earlier scene. For Red One, how did Sirius manage to be present? Sirus Black was a convicted murderer when he escaped from Asaman. All of the Witch wizards knew exactly why Black went to jail and the posters that were attached to every wall of the building would help remind them in case they forgot, with so much heat on his trail, how did Sirius manage to Buy Harry Potter a new broom? he can hide, recover some gallons of gold and continue his journey towards Redemption.

So how exactly did he get money and how exactly did he buy Harry's gifts? And that's all for this video. If you liked the

compilation

, please like the video and subscribe to the channel. Until next time remember that it is not okay to think about dreams and forget to live.