when two directors adapt the same book

gy it's time to bring the prisoners my Lord this is Paul trades I'm Paul V diva you bring from the nerves of denial Dune Duke of arus don't keep your back to the door he's about to put his hand in this box put your right hand in the box and he only has one question what's in the box pain and this is also Paul a trade I know this because I'm sitting with my back to the door in David Lynch's Dune you want a fixed suit before 1984 it's not the

same

character 40 years part your desert boots are fitted to desert fashion who taught you how to do that in two very different movies your suit is fitted to desert fashion who told you how to do it by two very different

directors

seemed like the right way seemed like the right way and Lynch's pool is also about to put his hand in the Box, put your right hand in the Box, this is how the scene begins in the old Dune movie and this is the

same

moment in the new one, you fired my mother in your own home, come here.

NE in Lynch's version, Reverend Mother's voice seems to have more of a mind-controlling effect on Paul, forcing him to consciously walk forward, but in the new Doom the voice seems more powerful. Come here. Neil the Ben can use something called a voice. In order to control the other humans, he will consider what you are about to do. Paul TR, his entire body has been controlled against his will and he is not happy about it. How dare you use your voice on me? Below we have the chart where you see this. Old Dune we don't have close-ups of it and it looks like a modern safe deposit box, but in Newon we basically follow the description that was in the

book

, which gives us a feeling of something ancient.

The same goes for g. haar I held your neck to g ha, we don't have closeups in Old Dune and it looks like a toy with a needle on the end and in the new Dune I held your neck, the GJ, we had a great time designing. I wanted those needles to be ancient. The point of this scene is to show Paul overcoming his animal instincts to avoid pain. Are you suggesting that a duke's son is an animal and how do they show this in ancient times? your consciousness may be powerful enough to control your Instincts Your instinct will be to take your hand out of the box, but in the new they only need one line.

An animal caught in a trap will tear off its own leg to escape. What will you do? This scene represents the differences between Dune from Denal Nerve. I would not do it. I've let you hurt my friends and David Lynch's Dune. I wouldn't have allowed you to harm my tribe, but first calling it David Lynch's Dune might upset David Lynch Dune. It didn't have Final Cut. I started selling it even at the script stage. It was a slow death, death, a terrible, terrible experience

when

it was released, it was not exactly well received, the biggest disappointment of the year is Dune, it was built as a great event film, Dune, the spectacular science fiction based on the novel by Frank Herbert about the future universe, but I can safely say that it did not live up to these expectations.

I think this is the worst thing coming out this Christmas. I really hated the movie. I guess I'm not in the mood today. Obviously both versions are based on Frank Herbert. The moods of the original

book

are cattle and love to play with, but with Vill Nur's version we finally seem to have the definitive

adapt

ation of Frank Herbert's story. You fight

when

the need arises, regardless of the movie before they camped on the top, give me flavor and the visual effects hadn't really reached a level to do justice to the story, but now we have a director who is no stranger to science fiction.

I have never retired something that was born before, that makes serious films with a strong atmosphere, what is the difference and best of all I love the books of being born is having a soul I guess every time someone asks me what was one of my greatest dreams in the cinema I always respond by

adapt

ing Dun the most obvious difference between V nur's version and Lynch's version is that a worm is the sign of the athetic worm this is kaladan in Old Dune I have to go ahead alone and this is kaladan in new Dune yes, I'm going to rakus tomorrow with him in Old Dune gady Prime is more industrial and A dirty athetic poison has been put into your body for many hours and there are elements of body horror like these poor animals.

By milking this soft cat body, you receive your antidote to a true obsession with bodies that open and emit various types of harmful fluids. The new Gat Prime is darker, more elegant and minimalist. G Prime is a plastic world, an artificial work taken from nature, a totalitarian environment and Arus is shown with many wide shots to establish the scale of the planet. There are times when, to create that scale, we actually do it physically. ran out of space the characters are very small in the frame the interiors often overshadow the actors and there is a grandeur and seriousness to the locations Sandw Worm is only 12 stories high this should be 45 stories high often that scale has that happen um being down on the ground level, while the old Dune is much more intimate in comparison, most of the scenes are within the 6th to 10th floor and the design is more detailed, it is very ornamental and full of paintings of intricate maps and high-cost costumes, if the fading you wish could join you. my sword in his hand look at fufi ha in the new Dune he is here my Lord and then in Old Dune you will do a formidable Duke Lynch version is more melodramatic get out of my mind he doesn't take you too seriously not until you say it Both , Who I Really Am While Newe has more weight to it, My Road Leads to the Desert is a very modern-looking film that goes for a grounded, realistic aesthetic, if you'll take us, and feels more like serious Prestige sci-fi. movie we'll come, while the old Dune is more surreal, it's elaborate, dirty and ultimately quite over the top, where's my doctor?

Phil takes his time building the world and setting up the characters, don't get your hands dirty with this animal, the plot unfolds slowly, let me take care of it. with it it leaves us enough time to think about the themes of the story each of these drinks every day the equivalent of five men is my load old dun is much faster the pasta but still has the same basic plot points this is a haonan animal please leave me my Lord, the atres arrive in Aus, how does it feel to walk in a new world? Paul finds a hunter, searches for a drone, they check on a spice collector who is attacked by a worm, it can't be easy working with sandworms, then the Haronian attack and Leto dies your bloodline ends forever Paul and Jessica flee to the desert is further than I thought they join the freman this is Duke Paul's son becomes lisen alib and rides the worm it's about throwing until he fights fades at the end May knife CHP and Shatter managed to get the right size of job, so what's the big difference?

Well, V Nerf is making their two movies and they lynch the one that was squeezed because in those days, the maximum length they calculated it could be was 2 hours and 17 minutes and that's what the movie is, it's the same story that plays out over 5 hours and 22 minutes in the new version, it runs to 2 hours and 17 minutes in the old version, it was like compacted, um, it hurt, it hurt, so what does this actually look like in the old version? Well, this is the first scene with Freman. I'll take the boy, there's no fight with Jamis. Paul does not have to prove himself to be accepted and chooses Freman's name at the end of this scene.

Could it be known as him? Paul mu and literally just 10 minutes later Paul is the leader of the freman. I'm usul Paul mu so again this is money talking so you don't miss a screening a day. I want you to squeeze and squeeze and squeeze, not for the This is only the second scene with Channy Johnny. I love you. I have always loved you. Only 20 minutes pass between the Atres arriving in Arus and the honey attacking all of V's nerves. The second part happens in about 45 minutes in Lynch. version that results in many expositions like this we don't know much about the fan they live in the deep desert some of them in the cities did you really think you could stand the quiz they have blue eyes inside the blue eyes the universe is super?

This being the movie, it spends a lot of time just telling us things. Planet Arus, source of the spice, which distracts from what would otherwise be a simple hero's journey. Which in depth we compare to Star Wars. They both have relatively similar stories. I give you the word Ben Jarate link. I was once a Jedi Knight just like your father with a lot of world building and laws Emperor Saddam the four well SK, but Star Wars works because it puts all this aside to focus on the characters, while Dune tries to juggle everyone. We just took space out of I on these aspects of the story, but there just isn't enough time to do them.

Justice for any machine in I. It ends up feeling rushed. Do you have any information on Arus worms and Too Heavy Exposure? That is the great lesson. Don't make a movie if it can't be the movie you want to make. Sightings of worms up to 450 m have been documented in the deep desert. It's a joke and a bad joke that will kill you, but, nun. has time to build this world more organically in araus we need to cultivate the power of the desert and set things up without being too explicit or intrusive power of the desert gradually reveals the LW in a natural way instead of just saying it to our faces it's the legend which is seamlessly integrated into the dialogue about the world and Grandpa fought bulls for sport, yes, instead of being told through clunky voiceovers, Spice pure and refined in Old Dune we sometimes get a close-up of a character while soft Reverb-induced internal monologues explain what they are.

I'm thinking he's hiding something about space. This is sometimes effective. I want Seer to not be able to catch me if I don't move, but it can often interrupt the flow of a scene. Be the difference. Yeah, maybe he would have made the movie start. with a big Exposition dump from Iran and then we know it's the year 10,191, then we get even more Exposition from the space guilds. Planet Kitan, home of the emperor of the known universe. This is very different from Nun, which begins with a brief narration from Channy. my planet oracus is so beautiful when the sun is low before we go straight to the story of Paul, the father wants you dressed to the nines before the Emperor's Herald arrives Phil Nerf saved the emperor for his second movie, while Lynch begins with him, yes, my lord, the same goes for destiny. who was introduced much earlier in Viejo, I will kill him.

Paul's sister was actually born. He's here now, but Jessica plays a much smaller role. Phil Nerve also includes many different languages ​​in his film. There was a dialect coach on set who made sure I had the correct pronunciation uh uh one day I was having an opportunity that was quite complex and I finally said okay we got it and the dialect coach came to me and said actually the pronunciation was not correct, I know, it was like I said, come on. brother, it is a false language, but in Old Dun it is all in English, take it to its desert.

Another difference is the inclusion of the Navigators guild. These are the guys who bend space and time to make interstellar travel possible. They are mentioned in the film three of Vn. Guild Navigators a total of 1.46 million 62 solarus round trip, but in reality we see them in lynchings and by 1984 the effects are impressive that we want, but the same cannot be said for the shields or the worms, today the visual effects are much more advanced, but This doesn't mean they always look great, but for Dune, paying attention to lighting, relying on practical effects, and using stronger cinematography makes the film look much more realistic than the typical Blockbuster, even when they use a fake digital camera. it still moves in a way that feels possible and realistic it will sound close to the spirit of a helicopter it shouldn't sound like a helicopter but in the same family look at this scene the camera is not used just to show the visual effects instead they are obscured by dust and smoke.

I wanted the design and technology to be familiar or here, where the lighting on the ship makes the image go completely black, something that you will immediately recognize and believe immediately. You won't question the clarity of the images, and sometimes seeing the most interesting element of the shot is sacrificed to get a more realistic image. I didn't want it to be distracting. Most importantly, I wanted to look as real as possible. This minimalist, grounded and deliberate approach seems to be the style of V nerv's film. His style is not direct, it is subtle, very formal and technically impeccable.

I found my own way, maybe you will find yours, which was my approach to protecting. the intimacy of the father story I found my way, but for Lynch's Dune it is the opposite, it is bold, detailed at the top and fast paced, Canley's ways have been obeyed, he throws a lot at the wall, some sticks and others do not control the observers, there are no signs that they are carryingAll in all, it's not really concerned with telling the grounded story, but rather pushing the strange and unique aspects of this world to the limit despite telling the same narrative, they are two very different films, one that looks like this, young cub, young puppy and one that looks like this, you are young F, you are young, one with characters like this you will have a new poison gas tooth and another with characters like this, exhale and you will fill the air with poison this is a performance in Old Dune no show the slightest mercy or pity and this is one in the new Dune Tam rock fades when Paul has his hand in the box at the beginning of the movie silence this is how Lynch shows his pain, the pain is not enough, but in the new Dune, instead of simply enduring it, overcomes it and we know it, not through any dialogue, but just a simple change in his expression, a musical cue, and some editing.

Thanks for watching.