YTread Logo
YTread Logo

Plagiat - Der große Bluff -- Krimi nach einer wahren Begebenheit (04/23)

Mar 14, 2024
Plagiarism the big

bluff

a crime radio play based on a true story, dear listeners, the following radio play is a crime thriller without blood, murder, police and even without a convicted perpetrator. Maybe it's worth pursuing it. Because the play is based on a hard-to-believe but true event that recently occurred at a German university, all the people who appear in our play and most of the places are, of course, completely fictional. In fact, neither the Georg University of Wittenfeld nor the university clinic with a chair of pediatrics located there, nor the Gabriele Medical University in Sofia, Bulgaria, nor the Scientific Publishing House in Dresden, are making a splash about the medical advances that will influence the development of the work. about hemophilus influenza, the causative agent of bacterial meningitis, are scientifically correct, but the bacteria played no role in the actual case.
plagiat   der gro e bluff    krimi nach einer wahren begebenheit 04 23
This radio play was inspired by the people who experienced such a case in reality and the plot is based on the data of the real event, but it is told with artistic freedom and now we hope you have fun with a story that would hardly have been easier to imagine with total freedom. Welcome to Heiligenstadt in 2019, colleague Holzinger is alone here, he probably needs a little relaxation right now. How are things going in pediatrics and recovery? In March I never sit in the room to have fun, I'm on call, colleague Freimuth, you know, but someone is always absent, why should it be different for us here than in another damn university hospital in this beautiful country?
plagiat   der gro e bluff    krimi nach einer wahren begebenheit 04 23

More Interesting Facts About,

plagiat der gro e bluff krimi nach einer wahren begebenheit 04 23...

Oh yeah, oh yeah, who do you tell? Staff shortages and overcrowding in Holzingen are the eternal song. We have already occupied the last bed in ward 3. After all, in oncology there are three wards. The children are given the honorable house for only a year and a half, we are chronically on the edge and even if your boss has a stone at the top of the board, as you always hear, you can say it out loud, dear colleague from above, how did he manage it must be that the gods have me back about the preparation before 300 is what no no just everything quiet finally it's time for the little ones I think it's already quite late oh, that was my colleague Holzinger colleague staschenk you, the pediatricians, They wanted to be with you anyway for a few minutes I'll let you go again I just wish you a peaceful night, you can still believe in a miracle, you can hear it broken again, it's still there, it's been over for weeks, my voice has to be In somewhere is constantly changing, nurses leave rooms and doctor's offices to leave all their old things alone.
plagiat   der gro e bluff    krimi nach einer wahren begebenheit 04 23
Just one of the many complaints here and you have once again blasphemed the professor. Your opinion of the boss has improved. just a small ward doctor. You don't have an opinion. Damn big animals put their protective hand on our tenured professor, it was like that from the beginning, that is, when she was still competing for a professorship, they say that's how she competes, yes, but that was a long time ago and yesterday's news I still can't access them, but now I prefer to eat bread, that was before your time, she was already a senior doctor like that, Hannah Smooth.
plagiat   der gro e bluff    krimi nach einer wahren begebenheit 04 23
Flying, ambitious and tremendously windy, she always knew exactly when she had to smile and who she had to drown. That's what we call it. Cyclist Franzi is no different everywhere, but as a citizen you have to be fair. woman you have to fight more like you do medicine anyway and she doesn't do a bad job, she has us too but it's always remarkable how clever she avoids difficulties even though we may not even know them all What do you want say with that? Question of private patient billing? That's just the most recent example. Then he just quietly turns his head to the accounting department and rambles on about it.
Too easy. He is also a friend from our Mrs. Professor Klatt's legal department and a good lawyer. Then little Monika Hübner died, her parents took her to court for medical errors, but the civil case was annulled in several cases. That was before her time. Gregori didn't hurt him, on the contrary, it's enough. "For an internal appeal. I've heard about it, these elders always cause stress and let's just say that they have recently re-created a website where they are clarifying the case. The untouchable Hanna is not in a good position there. She is now trying to file an court order or something.
Of course, our university leadership is once again firmly supported, from the dean to the presidium. She is the model professor, the pride of our honorable Georg Wittenfeld University and the academic world of Helikstadt Dorn. I understand why They are careful. She can't get enough of Gregorie, that's how things are, but at some point she will trip over something, I'm sure. Of course, said her colleague Freimuth. Before, how nice, you can still believe in miracles, I'm sure Eiler will arrive on time as always, hi Andi, hi Ayla, you had a nice weekend, everything was fine and you, what's up, who's the next celebrity you're going to behead, not funny Eiler, maybe that will happen again very soon, really is happening now, you know no interruption, you know, I live on scandals, so to speak, excellently investigated scandals, which distinguishes you from the sensational newspaper here, the feared Andreas Kurowski.
I already know why I like working with you. What did you discover new during Otto? More normal. I'm celebrating the weekend, I haven't heard anything yet, but I got an interesting call on Friday night. If there is something about it, maybe it's worth investigating. I will tell you that the call was anonymous. I'm always careful. A woman, why did she call? He claims to have solid evidence that there is a case of scientific fraud at the medical faculty of Hennigstadt University. Hospital with an older thesis, which would mean that someone is walking around for a long time with a PhD that they don't deserve, then it would be a case of plagiarism, well that's your specialty, someone obviously knew exactly who to turn to and Of course, still I don't know if this is classic plagiarism or another type of fraud.
The anonymous announcement sounded very emphatic, but the owner of the pediatrics chair, Professor Hanna Klatt, was apparently affected. She had already heard of her, yes, she made money as a specialist in children's meningitis, not only in Helligstadt, many of whom now come from far away to see her. The university clinic has become almost something of a national center of excellence in this field. Wow, is this a special disease, one of the most dangerous childhood diseases? I've already done some research, a bacterial infection is 80% fatal without a treatment that doesn't sound good and a joint treatment. Yes, there is this Dr.
Klatt. that she probably has the ability and started researching the topic from the beginning and that's exactly what it's about. You mean his dissertation is about that and there's something wrong with that. First of all, I don't want to say anything. This caller, who wants to remain anonymous, claims that they are important sections of the doctoral thesis that were not my own work oh that would be crazy and what is the claim based on, well the whistleblower announced that he would receive material in brief, let's see. As a precautionary measure, I immediately received a copy of Ms.
Klatt's doctoral thesis, it was not difficult, the university library also opens it on Saturdays. Here you are again very fast and what is your impression? He knows this profession well. within the limits dear Ayla within the limits I am not a doctor but this is not the first one I have selected and there are always similar ones Things to pay attention to when doing something like this, for example, it is experimental work with doctors, more well the exception. Most PhD students in human medicine will speak foul language in their dissertations. He did lab work, what do you mean by then?
Well, that was in the late 80s, the print version of it was published in 1990. Wow, so she's been in hers For a long time in her PhD, she had already researched this infection, exactly what she did. While studying in Munich, she began microbiological and biochemical studies on Haemophilus influenza type B: this is the title of her work. pathogen, this is the name of the bacteria that triggers the infection and microbiological studies are complex. With pathogens you have to meet additional safety standards, it takes time and cannot be done simply during studies, unlike the literature, the work of drs.
Certainly interesting, the Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich has graded this work summa cum laude, which is the best grade a doctoral thesis can get and now someone thinks I would have cheated, oh almost 30 years ago, well, possibly it's spicy that a death has occurred. After Mrs. Glatze moved from Pediatrics to Helikstadt, at that time she was a senior doctor, she already had her own beds and had bright career prospects in her department, but a little girl died and the parents were convinced that it was a medical error. This led to a court case, but in the end nothing could be proven for Ms.
Klatt. She survived unscathed on several occasions and was even appointed professor after her predecessor retired. The girl died of this meningitis. Apparently Dr. Klatt had treated her. If it fails, it is an unfortunate isolated case. In any case, no other critical incidents of this kind occurred or were no longer known, but the girl's parents remain convinced to this day that she tried the wrong method on her daughter. "Shit, that would be a big scandal, of course that's what it's about. Not here at all, friend, maybe it's an additional component, maybe it's not. I'll take a very close look at this PhD thesis.
At first At first glance , it seems solid, it was a blind alarm and in the meantime maybe I can get an interview with the professor. What do you think is a good idea? Think about it once and then we'll see what you can gather first hand. Yes, please , professor, the journalist would be there now. That's right, we had an appointment, should I send them? Oh, Mrs. Meyer Bär, and if you could please quickly bring the folder here to station 1, of course you can come in, thank you. you , good afternoon, Mrs. Professor Klatt, I'm Ayla Cicek, thank you very much for taking the time Hello, have a seat, they said that half an hour would be enough, which newspaper are you working for again?
I am a freelance journalist and he writes for several local newspapers and I am particularly interested in the career of, as I said, successful scientists, I am currently researching a new dossier on the topic of women in medical research. On this occasion I met her. she name several times. Yes, that's right, that's what they said before they posted anything, but no matter where you see the printed form, sure, well then they start. I have the next meeting in 25 minutes. Professor, you have dedicated your life to fighting meningitis, which is caused by the bacteria called Haemophilus influenza, a very dangerous meningitis in young children.
How did you get to this topic? If you are interested in infectious diseases and you are also interested in pediatrics because there are so many. In two approaches together we can briefly summarize what our readers should know about the bacteria: It colonizes the mucous membranes of people with weakened immune systems, the type B variant can pass through the bloodstream but also through the human brain. dangerous for very young children and have already researched the topic in their doctoral thesis. At that time we examined the effect of antibiotics on the pathogen. One of the topics was the antibiotic kinolohn, right?
Have you read my old work, which was almost 30 years ago? At that time we were also investigating substances from the quinolone group in Munich and you were particularly concerned about the so-called fluorine quinolone. Oh, you really read my work, right? We were among the first to be able to demonstrate that Fluor Kino Lohn is effective against the hemophilus pathogen. That was the beginning of his remarkable career, among other things, although of course we are no longer there, the knowledge that progress in science is growing rapidly, and that is a good thing. They are now well known for their success in treating this disease.
Professor, I would just be interested to know if the clinical studies in which you participated have not shown that this fluoride has significant side effects, so it is not even banned this year ah that is a mistake the Federal Institute of Drugs and Medical Devices recently imposed a restriction on the use of Fluor Kino is not the same as it has been a long time since we have used it here in Helligstadt even though it is approved, but if your file If I am going to take care of my career, there is no need to go into more details: time is running out.
As I said, I am a big fan of women who manage to succeed in science, especially in a field as dominated by men as human medicine. Without a doubt, we must fight, but I still have a question in relation to your thesis: it is true that the death of little Monika Hübner ten years ago was caused by fluoride treatment. Mrs Čicek, everything that needs to be said in this regard can be found in the press of the time. In any case, I will not comment further on the carsof the court if you have access to them. , but it is true that the Hübner family has recently started an online campaign against which they will have to act again.
My lawyer will take care of it, but little by little I begin to suspect, Mrs. Cicek, that you are not really interested in my remarkable CV, well, is this incident also part of it or not. Now you're getting picky, why are you really here? Am I wrong or do you mainly want to dig up things that have been completed a long time ago, but you know what my time is too? valuable for that reason, well the topic with the website is very current, professor, so you should have let me know in advance that this is what you are interested in.
I'm not available to play, who sent it to this poor person? parents, for example Child, no way Mrs. Meyer Bear, has she returned to her house? Yes, Madam Professor, the interview has just ended. Mrs. Cicek would like to go Unfortunately, I didn't hear much afterwards Nothing came of it Ayla, that was pretty good and I've made a lot of progress since Wednesday. I have the documents that the anonymous whistleblower had announced and yesterday you got the interview that goes like clockwork except for me. The professor sat upright in front of the door. , it still bothers me, like I said, don't worry, everything fits in the bed.
Maybe he could have been a little more diplomatic. I don't think you've hit any sore spots, although perhaps another aspect of what we're talking about. Everything's fine, I think we've got you guys caught up, in fact, I can already see the hunting fever shining in your eyes. Let's hear it, now you have real evidence of fraud on the part of Professor Klatt. I have carefully examined the document you sent me. You know that I never premeditated it carelessly; there have often been unfounded accusations with which some envious people wanted to speak ill from other people, especially in politics and science.
An accusation of plagiarism is made quickly, so it must be checked carefully, including the seriousness of the title. Breastfeeding intellectual property is not always serious, mind you. It depends on a little if from time to time you come across a passage from a doctoral thesis that was copied from another work without the author citing the source, it could have simply been negligence or carelessness, that is still no excuse, certainly not for you. You have to name your sources of information, but if there is a suspicion that help is needed, "You also have to check how important something like this is.
There is a wide spectrum, from quite irrelevant to very explosive. You make it really exciting, and what is it like in this case? Our complainant sent us a publication, more precisely, an anthology containing, among other things, an article by a certain Dr. Morescu and the content of this article can largely be found in Ms. Klatt's doctoral thesis: no There are only sections of text, but also tables and even an illustration - that's crazy. Look at it yourself, we have both works here, but I'll tell you something like that, I don't know it every day, it's almost bold, there wasn't even an attempt to hide the copying of the information, wow, but who copied whose doctoral thesis? article or vice versa, that is completely obvious, both are documents that are several decades old, but Dr.
Morescu's article appeared three years before Ms. Smooth's dissertation was completed three years. What kind of article is it exactly? ? Now it's getting interesting in an anthology summarizing the contributions of a scientific conference. According to the prologue, this conference took place in 1986 at the Gabriel Medical University of Kia in Bulgaria. A scientific publishing house A little less than a year later, the former GDR in Dresden published a special volume of its series on medical advances. Authoritative German translations of these lectures have been published, please wait for the German translations. The international scientific language was surely already English back then, but in the GDR this was still done, especially with the scientific contributions from the sister Eastern European countries, which were originally only published in the respective national language.
Back then, people often didn't speak any English and were therefore obviously the main target. group of this publishing house and today, after the fall of the Berlin Wall, science in East Germany has changed enormously. Much of what was published there was forgotten, which may be of crucial importance in this case, because of the way in which the medical advances of the small publishing house Dresdner became a victim of reunification the series had a limited scope since the beginning after 1989 there were no more volumes only in specialized circles they are still known aha and what is the volume they sent us about?
Special issue of the conference printed in 1987 No "It seems that it did not reach West Germany or modern university libraries. Our whistleblower wrote in an accompanying note that today, when old reference libraries are liquidated, it is mainly obtained from properties private, so he would have obtained his copy, But also in online antiquarian bookstores or even on eBay you can sometimes find something interesting, but in reality you almost have to know what you are looking for and in this magazine Anonymous has noticed in the article about this visa of Dr. Moresco. Now our whistleblower was 'I'm not very willing to provide information about the circumstances surrounding his discovery, but it has to be something like that, I think it's someone who has at least investigated the matter in detail and you also know Dr.
Klatt's dissertation, otherwise such a similarity would not exist. It is not even noticeable, especially if the publication had come into your hands by chance. It's really surprising that this is still coming to light now and you say that the similarities between the texts are significant and absolutely the article in medical advances describes studies. on the treatment of meningitis in early childhood that Dr. Moresco had tested the effect of several new antibiotics on the Haemophilus Influenza bacteria, including Hall wow, exactly the subject of Hannah Klatz's doctoral thesis and, as I said in the article, there are also tables and illustrations that I find one by one in the thesis of our model professor, which have not changed if all this is confirmed, Ms.
Klatz was obviously very sure that when she copied it, practically no one would find the original. She published her work a year after reunification, when everything in the scientific landscape of the former GDR was already in a state of turmoil. Maybe she thought the risk was negligible. It seems that it is. Aila, it just shows up again There is no one hundred One hundred percent guarantee that a body will remain buried in the basement forever and ever. Sometimes a long time passes, but suddenly something unexpected happens, like now with the teacher here. One thing is certain about this Bulgarian's work.
The doctor's work was presented to a specialized audience in Sophia four years before Ms. Glatzdoktorarbeit and the medical advances were published in a German transcript three years earlier. Glatzdoktorarbeit seems to have made generous use of it and this is a classic case of blatant plagiarism that We will first inform the dean of the Faculty of Medicine in Helikstadt about the case. If this fraud really occurred to the extent my investigations show, the woman must be confronted and the university must launch an investigation. that, her doctorate could be revoked only one university can do it wow for Ms.
Klatt it would definitely be the end of her career and it is also a hot story Ms. Meyerberg did you try again in the presidential office? Jakob Professor President Becker is here for you now, thank you Mr. Becker Hanna wanted to talk to me Siegfried, thank you for your time, we absolutely have to talk about this new incident that Dean Weidemann informed me about, as if I didn't have enough other things to worry about. This can only be absolutely malicious slander, I have no idea what the cause is. Coming corner, we will do everything possible to avoid any harm to you, I assure you, I have you, I trust you. but please also understand that I cannot leave this like this.
Of course, at first we will only investigate the case internally, but it has to be investigated, what I mean by this is that we need a commission, an official commission of inquiry at the university, then you can hand it over to the press. God, do you know what that means for my reputation? I know, Hannah, I know, but my hands are tied too. I have to get the code of conduct, we have clear rules, this is not just another story, which we can deal with without big problems, the reputation of the university is at stake and what has happened since then is already good.
Weidemann didn't tell me, he just told me. about it he reported the accusation and gave me a copy of this abstruse article who is the reporter Andreas Kurowski an independent investigative journalist but above all known as a plagiarism hunter he has already made some people cowards with something like this and that does it really disgusting? For us, especially at the beginning. Not true for me of course, but we should all be aware that Kurowski is now following the matter closely, which means the boy is already in the well, are you saying that's not quite it? Hanna Korowski is a professional and she has already had some Let Your Head Rolls, but she is not an expert.
She knows that scientific misconduct always requires scrutiny by experts. That's our job, but if our commission can't dispel the suspicion, the case goes to Munich, draws the final conclusion, you mean, take away my PhD, you understand what that means, it won't go that far, Hanna, I'm sure We are only at the beginning, but things have to move forward now and, as I said, we are going to create an internal commission of experts. I have agreed with this guy, Korowski, that he will not exploit the case immediately, but that she will continue to observe it. Actually, he is a very sensible guy, stubborn but also very careful, yes of course he knows that, now I know what you mean, Siegfried, but don't blame me for anything, what should the investigation commission be like? for medical school, but I think your elected ombudsman will be chaired by Dr.
Freimuth, the oncologist works on the commission, I will talk to him, I know that one of my senior doctors, private professor Dr. Holzinger, has always been hostile to Me, to put it kindly, perhaps this can be avoided, but I would be careful if I were you. Let the commission meet first, it will ask you for a written statement anyway and listen to it, then you can also express your concerns, great. And meanwhile, something like that doesn't stay confidential for long in these rooms, despite everything, I would say we have to be careful, because we are happy, as long as the tabloids don't notice and then the big bell is .
Of course, we have to inform the employees at the right time before rumors spread and you might want to take a well-deserved vacation soon, Siegfried, that would be immediately equivalent to admitting your guilt and you know it. It's enough. The damage has already been done, please don't expect any miracles, well, thanks for your time, Siegfried. Oh, I just remembered something. Just FYI, a young journalist, a Ms. Cicek, was with me the other day, supposedly to interview me about my career, but she also snooped quite a bit into my thesis. Something bigger is happening. I'm telling you, it's a game set up to get me off track the first time.
People when the coffee machine times. If it worked, it would be an expensive part and would break down constantly. Now I can go get the doubles on the fourth floor, so I won't even have to try them. Let me tell you, Hans is right that Professor Gossip is in trouble again. Yeah, that shouldn't cause a big stir, igori, and so far he's only informed a small circle, but I can confirm that he has new problems. There will even be an internal investigation committee. The investigation committee has again received a complaint from the patient. No, he has something to do with his doctoral thesis, what has to do with his doctoral thesis.
I'm sure it's been a while since you wrote your PhD thesis so loudly, yes, you're right, but someone has probably found irregularities by now. Something like this does not prescribe and, of course, it must be examined. Are you also on the commission? Maybe you can say Hans, or not. I would have liked it, but colleague Freimut, did the committee have a different composition? It's a shame, wow, problems with the dissertation, but shit can change if that's true. I don't want to be in The Boss's place. I do not want too. Come on, let's go up together.
The machine above probably won't break down either. Good evening, Mrs. Klatt. Please take a seat here in front, good evening, gentlemen. "Yes, thank you, Mr. Freimuth, we are not completely complete, but that does not matter. The student representative apologizes, as does Mr. Leutenbach, who was in the emergency room today. His colleague Krieg from radiology kindly agreed to take the van minutes I think we don't need a round of introductions or you know those present, thank you very much for taking the time, I know how busy everyone is, my written statement is available, yes, thank you very much, of course, we received them today from everyone colleagues on the Kennedy Committee.We would like to discuss with you the current status of our investigations.
Transparency in every phase is important to us. Thank you. You can imagine that I am very interested in the current situation. State of the process. At the end of the day, as you know, there is a lot at stake, but I think I can speak for everyone here when I say that we do not enjoy this task, it is not at all something very unpleasant, I can imagine, it is not that we do not They have nothing to do in their positions, they say so, but since I am the ombudsman of the faculty, I am there to please the leadership of the ex-officio commission, of course. , thank you, can I directly enter the house with the door?
How far away are you now? Have you already taken a closer look at Dr. Moresco's article that I supposedly copied it from, now you can do it with Wenzel? We are still busy with the evaluation, perhaps you would like to say something about it Mrs. Kannermacher, yes, thank you very much Mr. Freimuth. There are no errors in the content of the article, but it was not expected. The results of the cynological laboratory studies described in both works are all, except those of other groups, the accuracy of the data has long been confirmed, there is no doubt, is there not, Mr.
Wenzel? , the problem is not the content, but simply the intellectual authorship of the findings and I can only emphatically repeat what I told you in my statement. I wrote that we all did these experiments in Munich and evaluated them ourselves, regardless of what happens. It's in this article. You have already made it very clear, Mrs. Klatt, colleague Hucho, and this article by Mr. Moresko is not exactly one of the main journals of medical literature, on the contrary, I admit it. who previously knew nothing about medical advances. I only now realized them. Maybe it was an oversight, but obviously this publication was practically irrelevant to pediatrics, well except for that.
An exception as we now know, Mrs. Krieger, only now is it really surprising if you look at the more than modest circulation and, honestly, did any of you know about this series of publications before? Not me, maybe I'm too young, buddy. Kannenmacher in In cardiology, the series is really well known, at least among us in the older semesters. There were hardly any transcendental results published in cardiac medicine, but I must admit that it is possible that there were even one or two oncological ones. reports on medical advances. I can't exactly say that. But Mrs. Smooth, it doesn't matter why not.
We have to state as a fact that these volumes were produced in Dresden at more or less frequent intervals since the middle of the 19th century. 1960s until the fall of the Wall, then the publisher ceased operation, but some of the volumes can still be found in the collections of large libraries today, but I did not review that special volume from which Moresco's article comes. I would surely have found it back then during literature research for my thesis, especially on such a closely related topic. There is nothing more Article than the photocopy that Medikam left with Weidemann, he obtained it from Mr.
Kurowski, the The journalist who raised the case, as you know, has the original copy of the anthology, he would have made it available to us, but we consciously decided to achieve it ourselves independently of him. Oh and you got one, where can I say? Something about that, of course, colleagues Hugo, thank you, Mrs Klatt, it was actually not that difficult. In some second-hand online bookstores you can get the magazine. We found one there and we can buy it in online bookstores. That simply means that it cannot be easily found using the normal search tools used in science today, well, but that doesn't mean that it hasn't come to be that way at all, but now please think of three decades ago. "Nowadays we don't have all the electronic tools.
Specialized publications can be obtained with just a few clicks on the computer screen. Back then, weekend after weekend we still sat in the university's physical library and we would flip through the newly published journals for hours to stay up to date with the latest research. Yes, I can do that. Since this special report on a medical conference in Bulgaria in 1986 was probably not known throughout West Germany at the time, it is more than understandable that I simply missed a work published in it by a Bulgarian doctor who was completely unknown to me. It had to be that way, Mrs Klatt, we in the Commission definitely took it into account and, if that is the case, it must be that way.
It has been a double discovery, as is not unknown in science, because it is the only reasonable explanation I have left. We know more about the author of the article, this Doctor Moresco, perhaps they can find him so he can help clarify. The facts. Colleagues can say something. Unfortunately, Macher and I can't say anything. We also investigated this. Dr. Morescu died two years after the publication of his article, but we were able to verify that he was in fact a Bulgarian infectious disease specialist. who lived and worked in a conspiracy, then researched the same topic as me a few years earlier, so I can no longer rule it out and make note of it, but these results were apparently only published at a local conference in Sofia, Bulgaria, and then there were an East German transcript published by a small, long-defunct academic publisher from the former GDR.
Don't you think everyone will easily understand that this job just slipped by me, of course, Mrs. Klatt? but that's Unfortunately, it's not about two researchers coming to the same conclusion independently of each other. Yes, that exists and the fact that they did not know about each other has already happened a few times, but when two articles on several pages, including tables and figures, are as similar as their sections PhD thesis on the Bulgarian article then that is a problem, you yourself have seen this coincidence, of course I have, it is an almost incredible coincidence, but that does not change the fact that I had no knowledge of this other work; that is their point of view, Ms.
Klatt, which of course we absolutely respect, but the word incredible was said by themselves, that is the case, cracksus because there is a bit of similarity perhaps it can be understood but I can no longer be such a coincidence "We need another explanation. I can only repeat that it is an absurd coincidence, we will continue to investigate the other matter very thoroughly, I assure you ma'am." Suave, Ms. Kannebacher and Mr. Wenzel are attentive. Of course, we have already begun to review the other articles in the anthology and so far there is nothing unusual, except that they are all pediatric reports.
As I said, I didn't know anything about the whole subject, but Mrs. Smoothly, regardless of that, unfortunately I must add that one or two members of the commission also considers it unfavorable, that is what Dr. Moresco and her work on the antibiotic effect of flurkinolohn deals with and we all know it. "No matter how unpleasant the case of Monika Hübner was to you then, do not rudely relate it to he. We don't, Mrs. Klatt, we don't. That is not the subject of our commission's investigation, but some of us fear that the press will do that.
For them it could be a success and for the Hübner couple it is shit, pardon the expression, colleagues, but what else can you say about it, Mr Kurowski? Good night. I'm glad you could come, good evening, Dr. Freimuth. I was very happy to accept the invitation. We can take a seat. I brought my colleague Ayla Cicek with me, if you don't care about her, well, you don't have to care about her, sir. Kurowski, good night, Mrs. Cicek, sit down, good night, doctor. Thank you very much, but now I'm doubly curious, I'm glad, why should I care, before Cicek is also familiar with the matter.
I assume you have news about Professor Klatt's case, you head the university's investigative commission. Yes, I am the chairman of the commission investigating allegations of plagiarism against Ms. Klatt. The interview we did was an offer. You, Mr. Kurowski. , we will soon see why, but don't worry, it won't be a conspiracy meeting if perhaps you fear that. All I can tell you today and of course it will also be made known to everyone involved and the public. However, I thought that you, to be the first to know, I honestly assumed that too, Dr. Freimuth, good evening everyone, can you have something?
Of course, bring me a light mineral water. I will also carry one light and two still water. Would you also like the menu? Look, I would like to eat something, I also thank you very much, I will come immediately if you inform me correctly. I also had a conversation with the president, Professor Becker. If I may say so, I have a reputation for reporting that precisely in these cases I have committed myself: false doctoral theses, plagiarism, yes, that is what is known. because and in this case I held back a lot, but we don't have unlimited time ahead of us.
The story is spreading widely elsewhere because it is no longer a secret that an investigation has been launched against Ms. Klatt. by Georg Wittenberg University. So far we have kept the circle informed in any way possible, but we know they appreciate it. They were ready with their detailed report and the result of the expert examination, but finally the cat is out of the bag and the first damage is there. That was inevitable. Unfortunately, it is also not the only accusation Professor Klatt is currently facing, but we know that it is certainly an accusation with serious consequences.
We assume that if Ms. Klatt's doctorate is withdrawn, she will no longer be able to hold the chair of pediatrics or be clinical head of the pediatrics department at the university hospital, so she will surely understand that we were in We had to proceed with the utmost care when examine the allegations. , which lasted a few weeks and I thank you for your patience. To be sure, Ms. Klatt has not only made friends and she has been attacked on several occasions before. We also know that there are people who would be very interested in the resignation of teachers.
We will certainly be complacent, especially since the case of salaries in the cinema with little Monika Hübner, both legally closed, but probably not yet humanely closed, seems to be so and Professor Klatt also has internal envy, which is inevitable in organizations like ours, that is why we have followed the new accusations down to the last detail. I can tell you that we have now reached a conclusion, wow, that will be of great interest to many, first of all, it will be of interest to you, Mr. Gorowski, okay, now to both of you. Of course, then let's hear that it's like that.
You turned 180 degrees, what do you mean by that, Dr. Freimuth? I don't understand that either, what happened, basically I'll be happy to tell you from the beginning, his drinks, that was for me, please, and twice. mineral water, still, thank you very much, and here is the menu. Our chef recommends the venison ragout today, merci, we'll see, of course, listen to Dr. Freimuth. If he wants to try to impose some kind of university fraud. About me at the highest level, I must warn you that this will only make things worse. How do you usually proceed when fraud is suspected in a doctoral thesis?
This, of course, depends on the type of report. In most cases, I am only given the name of the person concerned and a more general accusation of irregularities at work. So nothing specific, no, I usually don't worry about it and sometimes a colleague like Ms. Cicek supports me. . "The work is formally in order, the sources, the citations, etc. Technically, my options are limited, but you'd be surprised what I still find. That means they also reviewed Ms. Klatt's dissertation for all of this, of course that we found I have to admit that the work looks very solid, but here we also had the Dresden issue of the Medical Advances series published in 1987 with Dr.
Morescu's article, that was all in io Opener, they also reviewed the article of course Within my possibilities, I was able to perfectly identify the author, among other things, a Bulgarian doctor who taught plodive at the university, he died relatively young in 1989, we also discovered that and for the rest, here is Publication date of the article We have the printing date of the volume and a dated foreword from the then president of the Gabriel Faculty of Medicine at Sofia University about how you received these articles. He would have had some ideas about that. Dr. Freimuth is slowly becoming an interrogator or something, I informed the dean that he had received the pamphlet anonymously after prior notice.
The sender had explained that it came from the estate of a doctor whose reference library had been closed. Other copies could also have been obtained this Well, better yet, but in online bookstores I have positively verified this and I could have bought another issue on Ebay, true, we actually bought our copy online but that is exactly where I have to say the problem begins . I want to say that this special volume, unlike other issues in the series, has not been published in any specialized library, but there is a very simple explanationfor this: the publisher published mainly in German during, I would say, The internal public of the former GDR, so the circulation was never high and a special volume like this then We probably paid less attention to this point than other volumes and discussed it in detail in the commission, Ms.
Cicek, but then he gave us some details that, of course, both of you would have only noticed if you had seen in more detail the progress of other Heiko volumes. I would have looked at the layout of the magazine, for example, the special volume differs in some places. of other editorial publications. It's just little things, but I can show you if you want, the message that we finally have in the committee. But it was clear that this time they had been deceived. Mr. Kurowski not deceived in Ms. Klatt's doctoral thesis. The point was that this plagiarism had to be proven false.
I don't think so, but you can be sure it was a surprise. On our side there was nothing less, We had never seen anything like this before, this little anthology that supposedly comes from 1987 is an A to Z invasive fact of a fictitious president's preface no, but an extremely well made forgery that you have to admit that you feel that you involuntarily remember the fake Hitler. diaries with which the magazine Sterne die Licht was published in 1983. Shit, honestly, it's not a cheap attempt with Mrs. Dr. Klatt once again trying to get her head out of her noose.
I'm ignoring you again, Ms. Cicek, Be sure I wouldn't be sitting here with you if I couldn't prove everything clearly. The truth is that at this moment I find it extremely difficult to believe. The fake is barely noticeable even at second glance. It was made with incredible care. Even the other articles in the volume are: To the extent that the works and their authors exist, they are original reports written at the time on the topic of meningitis and published in completely different specialized journals. They were compiled by the magazine manufacturer. , translated them into German and inserted them into his fake volume.
What a crazy effort! But that's exactly what makes it all seem so real and serious, except that Dr. Moresco's article was never written by him, but was compiled from the results of Ms. Glatz's doctoral thesis. It would be scandalous if it were true and the conference that supposedly took place in Sofia in 1986 also existed. Actually it is not, but it took us a lot of effort to get information from Bulgaria. people and actors from the university and Sofia at that time, including the president, are dead or at least can no longer be found, and the forger obviously knew this very well.
I admit I haven't gone that deep, but it all still seems extremely unlikely to me. Now I can tell you about the results of a forensic investigation, a forensic investigation, what do you mean by that because we had the age of the paper from which the notebook was determined? The producer has made every effort imaginable to make The Pamphlet resemble other older volumes in the series, but modern analysis methods urgently need to be deepened and the result is quite simple. The brochure is made of paper for modern laser printers, which can also be used by Internet providers.
Nowadays you can have your own books printed, our forger made several copies there, distributed them anonymously to various antiquarian bookstores and online book exchanges, one even posted on eBay and another shipped directly to you for later could be obtained from several apparently independent sources. I can believe it. Not who the hell gets into such trouble, but we also wonder, the goal is obviously to permanently destroy Ms. Klatz's reputation as a scientist, which she unfortunately achieved in part because at the university you can Of course, we don't carry carry out these checks in the back room. We know that there are now more people in the clinic than we are comfortable with who initiated the whole thing and maybe even carried it out themselves from the beginning.
I don't know, it has to be someone with a lot of specialized knowledge, otherwise such a clever fake can be created. We do not do that, we also believe that our job is already done, but we have verified the validity of the accusations. against Mrs. Glatze, the results of her exonerate her completely and without a doubt and we will also communicate emphatically to what extent we are searching for the perpetrators. That's another question, I think it would mainly be Mrs. Glatz's business or mine, because now that I'm the really embarrassed man in this story, she's encouraging me with a sophisticated plagiarism test, which itself was false, that's never happened to me. passed before, damn, I know one too.
There is no such case, but Of course, it is no longer a secret that they were the trigger for the entire investigation. Mr. Korowski, he calls him a plagiarism hunter, he is practically legendary, so if I may say so, he should think of something about how he wants to deal with the new situation Andreas, that's right, you can't leave it like this, maybe it's You better go on the offensive for your own sake and in the case of Ms. Klatt, even in this new constellation it is still a shameless story, perhaps even more blatant than if it were.
The suspicion against the teachers would really have been confirmed. Yes, why not? Her young colleague is right if she has a reputation for coming out as a victim of plagiarism if she is guaranteed to get a lot of attention there. the story, but maybe I should really tell it, let it go. Come on, look, the waitress is going to return, maybe we should order now and enjoy a good meal first, but you can think about it more, dear listeners, at this point we finish with our radio play Bloodless Crime, Murder, Police and In the End , the perpetrator was captured and was peppered with suspicions of resentment and fraud.
We leave our fictional people in Helligstadt behind and leave it open whether or not the author of the fake scientific journal will be traced and, if so, who he was. We have offered you some suspects Because in the real case on which our story is based, the client of the forgeries was identified and was sued for falsification of documents. documents, defamation, copyright infringement and fraud, but the highly professional ghostwriter who had actually prepared the fake anthology with which the dissertation of a well-known scientific personality was discredited. The intended victim was never discovered in reality, but only after a competent and careful process.
After careful examination by experts, the intended victim was rehabilitated. What's left is a deluded plagiarism hunter and the worrying realization of how quickly even professionals can fall for fake news. We wish him a good day or a good night and always remain aware that he has heard about the great plagiarism.

bluff

a police radio play by Stefan Fabry the speakers were a certain Cicek Nadine most Andreas Kurowski Thorsten Möser Professor Dr. Hanna Klatt Anke Bothe Dr. Freimuth Moritz zammert Dr. Hans Holzinger Matthias heil Dr. Gregory staschik Andreas Strohmeier Professor Dr. Siegfried Becker Lars eichstätt Dr.
Hugo Marion Koch Waitress Laura Hensel Mrs. Meier Bär Anja Lukas Dr. Kannenmacher durle Hoffmann Dr. Wenzel Florian Rosenberger Dr. Krieger Narrator Thomas söcker Introduction and credits Philipp Böser Editor-in-chief Alexandra Begau Director Music and sound editing Stefan Fabry Design cover Anja Klukas Sounds from freesound.org and yours This radio play was created as part of a project at hör talk.de and is licensed under the Creative Commons 4.0 2023 license.

If you have any copyright issue, please Contact