Roy Keane & Jamie Carragher clash over their combined Liverpool 2020 and Man Utd 1999 XI | MNF

So for the last two weeks we've been asking you to pick your

combined

11 from the treble-winning Manchester night, apart from

1999

, to this Liverpool team who are marching towards the title and could yet win the treble. The Eurocup in a couple of weeks is going to be very difficult, something is what you have maintained, this team has not won, nothing is going to change, you accept that except the Champions League, yes in terms of the League, oh yes, late I told you that I didn't want it yet, but Of course it's done and dusted but it's not officially done yet so this is going to be interesting because of course Road was part of the

1999

team and Jamie has one eye on Liverpool so why Why don't we start with the goalkeeper Jamie? and give us your verdict between Peter Schmeichel and Alison.

Well actually down south Alison made a stop and actually set a comment. That's why it's the best goal, keep it away and I think right now I think Alison is the number one goalie in the. world, but I think where Michael played he was also the number one goalkeeper and it is probably said that he is the best goalkeeper for everyone. I think he's the standard everyone tries to get to, so I got a Peter Schmeichel. I suppose you would. Okay, yes, I agree with that. I wouldn't say I really like Peter, but as a goalkeeper and as a character, yes, you would want him in goal, so I agree, well, what was he like with his feet?

Peter is not great, but the most important thing was that he was good with his hands, you know, back then, obviously, it was inaudible to play from behind, but Peter obviously saved us a lot of important games, great personality, great character, like that Yes, a tough guy, listen, I do. I have burst something. I have said it before. We never blow up with a teammate. Sometimes he's good, he kind of cleared the air, but listen, we were pretty good afterwards. How many rounds did he do? Do not listen. Obviously there was alcohol involved. No, Peter. Now he is a very good goalkeeper, good character and a great player who escaped and we had success with him at United.

He played as a great teammate at right back. Possibly we should have left this for last. Gary Neville or Trent Alexander Arnold think something like this is very serious. I think we have to judge it on this season alone, biscuits, munchies, United play small, strange, big curries. I'm looking at these little people, maybe it's just this season. I don't think Gary Neville has had a season like Alexander Arnold's. Gary Neville didn't have the influence at Man United in that sense, Alexander Arnold has in this Liverpool team, that's what I would say, so I think the trends are just because he has a bigger influence in his team than in Manchester , Yeah.

I agree with that side, I think he's been outstanding this year, we can look at the defensive side of him and he needs to improve, and I'm sure he will as he gets a little older. I think it's a hash. time Gary because he obviously he's a former teammate, but yeah, James made some good points there and if Gary has to miss, be a Buddha, but Gary was a general we talked about. I think the key to being a very good player, a top-level player. It's being consistent and Gary was and obviously I went through a lot of battles that were loud so it's very difficult for me too, it's like seeing who's a better player than who because I've got Lloyd Lee with my teammates well we'll do it. .

Let me put it this way, if Sir Alex Ferguson had picked this team, do you think he would have picked Trent? Alexander Arnold. I would never do it with Gary, no, no, because he obviously doesn't like him in the game and I think even Gary would admit that Trent is amazing. It's been going forward, but I guess at the moment we play there's more to it than playing and adjusting what you've looked for, obviously Gary defensively was very solid and the product was pretty decent up top and on the field, he and Becks obviously had great chemistry between them, but no.

I'd say Malik's verbosity would pick Gary even now, let's go over our fullback Sen Robertson instead of Owen or I'd pick Dennis Aaron. I think he was a brilliant fullback, I wouldn't say. I thought he was underrated as someone who probably hasn't been talked about as much as he should. I would choose Dennis. When you know the goals he scored, he was good. You think you really know the set pieces, the penalties. No. I think he was a brilliant listen. I think Robertson has just been a revelation, what he's done and probably a similar story to everything to come.

I come from Oldham, not for a big transfer fee to Manchester United. Robertson has done the same, but I would go with Dennis here when I'm sure you would too, yeah, no argument. Oh, Nelly, since I've played with her throughout my career. Dennis, you talk about the modern fullback. Dennis could play as a left back. Broke for a number of years but brilliant Ireland and United player Dennis is a great player. The honorable and inconsistent of him Dennis of him was an 8 out of 10 most weeks, the standout and always on form, always on form when we got to the central area.

I guess I don't think it's fair enough to say that we'll put a guy here on the side to seal what one would tell you, Roy, who thinks it's best. So I think Van Dyke is better than Stan, yeah, at least I do. I'm a big fan of Van Dyke, I think the journeyman, I think he's the guy, he's a machine. I've said it before but he was still a machine, yes he was fantastic and Van Dyke would probably play the board better and yes probably but again. yap, it was a great team here and for them together, you know you couldn't imagine considering too many goals from them.

What did Stan actually have in my wear? I did it when he came in again. We always talk about that. When people talk to players I've played with, people write about

their

, I guess, technical abilities. I always think back to the type of personalities we encounter, but you're Spencer the entire time we're together, you're obviously training. field and locker room trips and medals and yes, he was a brilliant guy, brilliant, good family, came from good roots, good background, brilliant player and, again, just as important, the brilliant character, big mistake when he left, big mistake Yes, yes, but I didn't want to. injuries to you, I know if you remember, I think about the Achilles injury, but yeah, big loss when he left, put Dustin in shit, the game you're in, you know, sure, come on, big personalities, but it was a big loss, so go.

As a box-to-box midfielder, a sitting midfielder because you do everything, you really do whatever you want, yeah, obviously. I want my career to change when I was a younger player, obviously a forest. He was more of a box-to-box player. get - try to get a goal I didn't send a forced element here my game changed. I received a blower. I'm becoming more of a sitting midfielder, but yeah, my chances of doing a job there, the Liverpool team, yeah, yeah, she talked. You're there I think the team I want to pick up on what he thought about this.

Actually, let's not forget it. You're not disagreeing with me and the team I made my night play for Liverpool plays 3-3, so I. I'm going to play a 4-3-3 because I think that's the system that most teams use now, so I think you and that's all and all you play there probably towards the end you could shout offer, yeah, anticipated, without a doubt, one of or the best central midfielder in the Premier League, who is actually what I'm saying? You know, I know, listen, no, absolutely, no chance, listen. I was a very, very average player.

I was very lucky. You know, the key to my career was always. I walked towards really good players who almost took me very, very lucky, this Paul Scholz kept his place in this

combined

team past yes, scores II again. I don't think that's up for debate. I would put the scores up there, I guess the Dennis situation and I assumed that Van Dyke is a non-offer, so he thinks differently, it's causing the no scores, it's a big game reveal. In fact, I think the midfield you are looking for is possibly one of the best, if not the best.

The best midfield we've probably seen in British football. You think it could be the Liverpool teams around United, the Chelsea fire, whatever it is. I think it was great, but we played for three, three and the other in your midfield. I'm going to answer them inside and in fact I think Beckham people talk about Beckham because of the fate of his celebrity status almost that he made it and this global name and he wasn't that good of a footballer. Actually, I don't agree with that. I think that took away from how good he was as a footballer, people sort of forgot how good he was because that wasn't what put him there as a world star back then.

I think, in a way, it was a little bit on the go, but that's what your teammates appreciated um-no, oh yeah, and basically that's the most important thing, is what your teammates think of you, that It's the respect you seek. Whatever Beck is, I guess, fame outside of the game. We always appreciate it when we talk about modern players, you know, doing jobs. Beck for all his brilliance, what he started on that wing, stepping back, helping Gary, moving forward, getting goals, getting assists, so we were never, ever distracted by anything like that because we appreciate what he brought to the team he was a good coach yeah , all these lights here what I'm talking about all good coaches all of them that's what you were worried about is that kind of prominent figure in the locker room when all this was coming up David Beckham's style no, no, really because it's part of my work or some of the veteran players and we returned to its realization.

You'd be on the lookout for these guys, you're talking about progress, distractions for modern players and me. He had just fallen hard and a player, if I tell you, gets distracted by things off the field and whatever Beck was doing off the field, I never felt at any point when I looked at him on the train that he was taking his eye off the field. . For me, the ball was still his love and his focus was football, yes he had Ollie a bit and good luck to him, that was up to him, but first and foremost he was a footballer.

Does that three work for you work like a three with Beckham? stuck in there yeah I'm just worried about where we're going to put the other United guys in Giggsy hmm Giggs isn't going into my team RG no that's fine I've got three forwards just drop that bomb and I'm moving. in Oman, you don't judge by this cleavage, it's him in season 99, yes, you know, a lot of goals he scored that previous season, enough for you to get an A team, no, but okay, let's move on to my three. I'm going to have, I think my right now is the best left tackle or left end in the world.

I think I love Ryan Giggs, one of the greats in Premier League history, longevity, all that pain etc, I don't think I'd probably ever stay there. He was probably the best in that position, you may not agree, you know I'm better than me, but I actually think the numbers mine is getting now or a lot more than what Giggs was getting, but you're enough city for greatness to be consistent. Giggsy did it. year after year and something, you might have the odd season where it could be a 10 order 10, but you want to put that season, it's about whether the big games look like idiots in the semi-finals, tell me, one player on this planet I could have done that.

He does it well, why did he have so much rotation? Because we, but Blancas was behind him, that's what makes you win to a large extent. Yes, he was a very, very good player. He tells me that he doesn't make it to this team, but you need a team to win. great trophy, you know that, right? Yes, well, it's not just about eleven, that's why Liverpool rotate his sentences, that's why he didn't want to play in the FA Cup, rest and rotation, we got them, we had to do it, yeah. let's hope they win three trophies, are you sure I'll be there, yes, sorry you missed the final there, I've suspended you, yes, I know I got injured, I got injured, yes, so you're putting on concerts, yes, instead of mine, eh, yes. on the back scoring three goals and two assists no, but like I told you, the key for me is to be a consistent player, but my knee doesn't end, you can't juju mining currently no, but I'm getting slightly closer to the guillotine.

I don't know Manny, so it's a little, then the rest comes. I'm going to go forward right at the top of the field and I'm going to go for most of the sellers on the right for Andy Cole to come. I think I get it, you won: I'm here to finish. What do you think about that? The system obviously did it. This system you are playing is difficult to achieve for Collie and your key. More or less, but I think it's York in front of Colt outside York and calls, so could you come out? So you're talking about the net season you can call obviously Teddy Nollie behind it was fantastic so you're honorable if it's just for that season how can he?

Do you leave your key or do you call when to call I scored 20 goals plus substitutions for 20 goals now and there is still a war how much time is left we forget about these little hairs we have not lost the game yes, we have also won the league yes If you were wondering what they have won this seasonStill, would you like to go back a few months ago and went to a trophy tree? Yeah, um, obviously, but you're torn by this Liverpool team. I think it's brilliant. I can't speak highly enough of them. I think it's great the record of the last year or two or just 105 points or it's mind-blowing, but it's hard for me to do this because I have loyalty to these guys that I was in the trenches with.

I loved them all, they were my teammates. It was difficult for me if you're having a debate about a certain player. I can go with one of my teammates. I have one of the teammates. I'm sure you understand that no, we get it, but I'll backtrack with arguments as to why. I'm going for that player, yes of course, and I understand that, but I think you're wrong, so your conclusion about your team for 33 with York, Seller and MANET on either side now is, um, what we do brought an interesting mix from Liverpool. I'd probably stick with Alyssum.

I would stay with what we had in the statistics. I'd probably bring in Van Dyken, maybe the right backs, but leave the rest for you to call upon. So we'll end up with my team or Roy's team for a bit until he really wants a change, but I'll do it, you can, so that Salle is out, the man who scored 47 goals as top scorer in every season in which It is, yes, you put it. those concerts are good, I give you mr. Team Jimmy, so your thought on the opinion surely said it. I understand what you're saying 100 percent.

What do you like? What about my father? Because I won't agree with you. That's your opinion. You just think about entering and even adding an ID. so maybe I push Gary on his right back because Gary understands what it takes for the Salford game, this little team. I think right now, with the season it's not over, but I think you want a window if they continue. I went to Trimble this year, no. I don't know, we love this different conversation, of course, it's just illegal, it will be enough, no, do you think the treble can't be surpassed, but do you actually think that the usual United team won the league and the European Court was the better in the triplet?

Do you think it's about the actual trophies you win that season or say yes, when you add teams it helps if you can back it up with trophies, but I look at some of the teams. favorite join I think they are so we asked ourselves double in 94 that was a brilliant team you know you haven't mentioned we can start talking about some of those players the Canton is that they use fabulous players but in 99 I was in the office here there It was a special year and we the only thing you have to use in the world that I always used when I look back on my career, some of the players or the trophies you might owe, you need a little luck, you need some breaks and We had some that year that They seemed united, I think they finished with 79 points, although people got 76 now, I know, but that's not going to end, it's ridiculous, you can talk about it, but when you win the league, you talk about points in twenty-five points.

The bottom line is that when you win the trophy, you get a medal, you don't turn it around and say how many points you earned in the league. Boy, look at that thing because you've worked hard for it. Liverpool, an incredible record reason. Great, then, if that Liverpool team won the treble, just in case, let's say yes, would you put? How many more Liverpool players do I think will come in? Probably two more, who would you put? No. I like Manny and Salah, so what's right? the first one no, no, but my light is towards oh, I have to say, my light is towards my team, so as things stand you wanted to go with Virgil van Dyck because the only one, yes, he would have to come in and Ronnie Johnson, what is it. unfortunate but lovely Ronnie, if he took Virgil Van Dyck out of this Liverpool team, yes what would be the impact if you take two goalkeepers?

It was going to be a lot of Lester's team because we saw in recent years when Liverpool were quite good in attack. I never felt like we were going to win the big prizes unless they bought a centre-half and a goalkeeper. I guess that's what they did so I don't know why Clop wasn't coaching love races in all these guys thought what a great pitch she was he said he'd like to go and buy some players a surname, again it seems like that's it our final thought. I think that's a good point, let us also know which teams you decided to pick if they are different than the Rockies.