Dalia Dippolito Retrial Opening Statements 12/07/16

However, I apologize for the delay, it is now the jury that is sworn to hear and consider this case and ultimately decide this case. And before we begin, what I want to do is explain what your role will be in this case. and what my role will be in this case, they are very different roles and do not overlap. Your role in this case is to decide all factual issues and you will do so by rendering a verdict at the conclusion of the trial. the case for you to decide issues a fact my role in this case is to decide issues of law these roles do not overlap you should never think that I prefer one verdict over another and reaching a verdict is exclusively your job you already know this is a case criminal is the state of Florida against Doia Dealo during jury selection I warned you about the charge it is a solicitation to commit first degree murder with a firearm it will be your solemn duty and responsibility to determine whether or not the state of Florida has proven all and each of the elements of the crime charged Beyond and to the exclusion of any reasonable doubt, before we continue, I want to give you a brief overview of the trial process, what you can expect in the coming days and just a moment when the attorneys will making an

opening

statement an

opening

statement is what lawyers believe the evidence is going to show in the case an opening statement is not factual evidence what the lawyer says at any time is not evidence the actual evidence that is going to go into the case case can come or it can come in several different ways one way the evidence can come is through Witnesses testimonial evidence the witnesses will appear here live in court they are going to take this witness stand to my right they will be Sworn to tell the truth and They will testify here in front of you, that is testimonial witness or evidence.

Another way evidence can enter the case is through exhibits or documents. Evidence or documents are received as evidence and will be marked and preserved. by the clerk now many times a lawyer can put a document or piece of evidence into evidence and they don't show it to you right away and you're left wondering, well that's evidence, can't I see the evidence? Please be assured that any exhibit or document that is presented as evidence, you will have the opportunity to review and will return to the Jury Room with you when you deliberate, so if for any reason you are not immediately shown a document or exhibit that is presented as evidence, don't worry, it will. see that document or exhibit however, during the course of the trial the attorneys can also present an exhibit or document as evidence, they can look at me and they can say judge, can we release that exhibit or document?

What that means is that they want you to see that evidence or document immediately for consideration in relation to the testimony being offered in the case. Now there are a couple of different ways a document or test can be published to you. One way is to simply hand it to him. Simply put, if it is a piece of paper, a document of some kind, you can give it to them. Each of you will have the opportunity to review it. Simply pass it to your neighbor. After everyone has had a chance to look at the document, place it back on the jury bar. we pick up Pick it up and return it to the clerk, so that's one way to publish a document.

Another way to publish a document is by using an overhead projector. We'll set up an overhead projector here in the courtroom. the document will be placed on top and that is basically another way to publish a document so that everyone can see it at the same time, also videos that can be played or presented as evidence, would have to be displayed through that method, so that's another It's a simple way to publish evidence or documents that are received as evidence. A few words about testing before leaving that topic. Lawyers are trained in the rules of evidence and procedure.

They owe their clients a legal duty to raise objections if they consider it appropriate. An objection has been raised. My typical practice will be to call lawyers to the bench. I'll play that annoying white noise you heard earlier. I will discuss the objection with them and will rule on the objection now if I overrule the objection. objection, obviously, you will hear that testimony or see that Doctrine or proof, for example, if there is a question, ask for interposed witness objections. I overrule it, obviously, you'll hear what that witness has to say. The same applies to a piece of evidence or a document, if I overrule the objection, you will see the piece of evidence or the document;

However, if I sustain an objection, I must not speculate on what that evidence might have shown or demonstrated, in other words, if a question is asked of a witness, the objections are raised. sustain the objection do not speculate about how the witness could have answered the question the same applies to a document a document exhibit is offered as evidence I sustain the objection do not speculate about what that document could have shown or demonstrated let's just move on now because the Lawyers have a legal duty to raise objections during the course of the trial. An attorney or party should never be faulted for raising an objection.

That's your job. They should not even be blamed if I overrule the objection, regardless of my decision. if they make an objection they are doing it because it is their legal duty to do so, never hold it against the party or an attorney for raising an objection, that is their job, after all the evidence has been received a couple of things will happen further. Number one, you will have a closing argument by the attorneys, a closing argument that the attorneys believe the evidence has shown or perhaps from their perspective was not shown during the course of the trial, just like an opening statement, a closing argument It's not evidence, it's simply what the lawyers believe the evidence has shown or not.

It's basically the end of the book opening, the beginning they stand up and say this is what we believe the evidence is going to show in the conclusion, They stand up and say we believe this is what the evidence has shown or maybe not from their particular perspective. Also, at the end of the case, you will receive your legal instructions for me, that is the law you must follow in this case. It is my practice to give each of you a printed copy. Of those instructions, I am required by law to read them to you here in open court, but as I read those instructions to you, you will have a copy in front of you.

He will have them to return to the jury. During your deliberations, you will not have to memorize the law that will apply in this case or guess about that law. I'll give you a printout of those instructions, so it's kind of an overview. of the trial process, from the initial statement to the closing of the legal instruction with the evidence obviously in the middle. Uh, couple rules. I want to go over some of these rules with you. um, you've heard over and over again some rules that you haven't heard yet. I'll start one with one that you haven't heard yet and that is: keep an open mind until you've heard everything, in other words, don't come to any fixed or definitive opinion about this case until you've heard all the evidence. you have heard all the lawyers' arguments and know the law you must follow.

We would certainly like you to think about the case as the evidence is received, but do not come to any fixed or definitive opinion about the case until you've heard everything and then obviously when you get back to the Jury Room you start deliberating. , then it's time to start forming fixed opinions about the case as you discuss the evidence collectively among yourselves. I know the rules they will get. sick of um I will I'll make it a little shorter today because you've heard them over and over again these are extremely important rules you can't communicate with anyone about this case including communications between yourselves. until you send them back to that jury room to deliberate and at that time only between you communicating includes any form of verbal communication any form of written communication any form of electronic communication Twitter tweet email blog post Facebook post no communication related to this case there is no investigation regarding this case you cannot look up terms in a dictionary visit the scene of any alleged event in this case you cannot do any type of investigation at all it is extremely important that all jurors hear and consider the same relevant evidence and that is what I presented here in this courtroom, if you did your own research, the attorneys would have no idea what you relied on to reach your verdict in the case.

The reliability of that evidence cannot be proven in any way, so it is very important that you decide this case based solely on the evidence presented here. I have indicated time and time again that you cannot hear or read any news of this trial. Extremely important, um, those three instructions, as I said before violating any of those instructions could cause a mistrial, meaning we would start the whole process over. Most of you were here for most of the jury selection process. You know how long this trial has gone on at this point. This would get us all started. case once again, so comply with the three rules.

If you don't have pads in front of you, you don't have pads for an obvious reason. You are allowed to take notes during the course of the test. You are allowed. You don't need to take notes. If you choose to take notes, it's up to you. If you take notes, some things you need to know are number one. Don't let note-taking distract you from listening to the evidence. It is extremely important that you listen. carefully to the evidence presented here, so don't let note taking be a distraction number two, your notes are privileged, no one has the right to review or read your notes now, the reason we ask you to sit down in its assigned place. seats is so that you always have your notebook after each break and we come back during the night and as I said last night it's a pretty simple system, it's just 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 so you know the number you have in your notebook, that's your notebook for this trial when you arrive in the morning or after your lunch break, make sure you have your notebook at night.

When we take a break, the officer will pick up those notebooks and they will literally be locked up overnight. At the end of the trial, the officer collects his notebooks and his notes are immediately destroyed. Nobody reads them. You should feel free to place whatever you want in them, safe in the knowledge that no one will be looking at them. notes now, when you go back to deliberate with your fellow jurors, if you want to share something that's in your notes, that's fine, you're basically the one waving that privilege by saying I remember the first day this witness said and whatever you have in mind. your notes, are you collectively. share your recollections of the evidence in the case so that you can share whatever you want to be in your notes with your fellow jurors when you return to deliberate, the point is simply missing, you wave that privilege, no one will have the right to read your notes and As I said, you should put in your notes what you feel comfortable putting there and be confident that no one is going to take a look at those notes.

I think I went over most of the logistical rules with you last night. I talked to you about what you can and cannot bring to the courtroom. I remember asking him to remember to wear his jury credentials at all times. Remember if you see the attorneys or parties outside in the hallway at any time by the elevators. or wherever it is they are going to ignore you because they don't want to violate my instructions not to have any contact with you um and so please keep that in mind if you see any of the lawyers or parties outside as I indicated.

Before, from now on, you will enter and exit this courtroom through the Jury Room, back through the judicial hallway, that is how you will enter and exit and that should minimize your accidental contact with the attorneys or the parties . I want to repeat. An instruction that I have given you before is an important instruction, but it is worth repeating at this time in every criminal proceeding, a person accused of a crime has an absolute constitutional right to remain silent and, if he chooses to exercise that right, he cannot inferring guilt from that you can't use that in any way and you should never care about whether or not an accused person got on the witness stand.

I know you've heard that before, but it's worth repeating right now. The preliminary instructions that I have for you right now we are going to have the attorneys' opening

statements

. Opening

statements

, as I just said, are what the attorneys believe the evidence will show in the case, we start with the state. Mr. Williams, are you doing the opening? Okay, everyone welcome back to day five. The good thing about this case is that it is 100% based on merit. Words, your actions and your intention 100% and that's what we're going to present to you, so I did it. I made a little outline for you guys to follow and as we go through the test, I put a little check mark on each of the exhibits that appear so you can follow along as we go, so I made DD ISO.

MD is Michael DPO who is the husband she was going to kill on August 5, 2009. Mrs. is Muhammad Shahar. Mr. Shahar wasM Leo's friend who she was trying to get to try to find someone to murder her husband and then WJ is the clever Hitman Jean, he's Beach's undercover police officer and I call it, um, so simple. Mr. Miss Deito and Mr. Deito met in the summer of 2008, so about a year before she tried to have a structure, she ends up buying this house 1329 viel Pepe in Boon Beach and all this happens in an area short, the recordings, some of the meetings and everything in a kind of closure, it is close to Congress and Gateway Inon Beach and bought the house. in January 2009 and she moves in with him they get married in February 2009 so 6 months later she is trying to murder him and it actually starts before that but let's get into it so the Boon Beach Police Department gets involved for the first time on July 31. 2009, that's Friday and what happens that Friday is Mr.

Sh is so worried that she is serious about her husband being killed, he can't take it anymore and shows up at the BL Beach Police Department and tells BL Beach police. department that he's worried that this woman is seriously going to have, they think he's crazy, he doesn't know that we last, so all kinds of things, they don't know what's going on, so they talk to him for a while and decide, you know . what are we going to record this so they can record a statement you won't get most of the recordings CU say um but you still don't know if it's real so this is July 31st we're getting closer yeah e e e so you investigate, you try to find out to find out what's passing by, they talk to Mr.

Sh and he agrees to come to Poli the next day, so now we are on August 1st, which is Saturday, and on Saturday at 3:35 they record a phone call between him and Miss Dilo. and he tells her that he will meet with her and that they will meet with her to tell her that he has information about a person that he can really kill for her, so he tells her that there will be another recording. We'll hear it at 4:12 p.m. also on Saturday and tells Mr. that he is 10 minutes away and then at 4:15 sometime after 4:15 uh, while these phone calls are being made, they are putting a video camera in his car so that Drive to a mobile gas station. station in that same area and meets with the accused and she gets into her car and they discuss the details, he tells her who this Hitman is.

A little, very little information about who will let him go, he will give you his name, phone number, things like that. I'm going to play it for you pay close attention to her words close I'll have to play it for you more than once so you can get all the details um they discuss the money how much money does she give to Mr. Shah $1,200 she tells it I see in the video that she hands over about $1,200, which is $200. He says it's $200 for him and $11,000 for the h. He buys a gun, so Mur needs to buy a new gun for the murder to happen.

She provides a photo of Michael DPO. and a photo of that house and she points out to Mr. Shah where he lives, so she pays close attention to all those things, so that's August 1st. Mr. Shahadi tells him not to talk for a while. The next day is August 2nd. it's sunday no activity sunday august 3rd it's monday uh 11:38 in the morning there is a recorded phone call M tells misso that Hitman will come today to meet you um he asks Mr. Shahid to try to be there so that come with her to meet Hitman and he says he will try to come and meet her. 10:04 pm Merito tells Mr.

Shah that Michael, her husband, Michael Dilo, will go to a bank on Wednesday and take out $10,000 from the bank and give it to his business partner and that there they can kill him and keep $ 10,000. You will hear that call number six is ​​at 2:47 p.m. This is the first call between Mr. Jean, the hitman, and Mr. Leo. He calls her and tells her to bring $3,000 in cash to her house. I'll be up in an hour and I'll call her when I get close so we can. talks about where she tells me driving down the U at 3:08 p.m. so shortly after hanging up the phone call with Hitman, she calls Mr.

Shah again and tells him what the Hitman just told her: he wants 3,000 dollars and he wants to have the key to my house and she complains about the 3,000 he gave her. I just gave I gave $1,200 and I can't get the $3,000 and I don't want to give him the key to my house because then he can rob me and how do I know that they are going to kill my husband and this is not just a scam, pay close attention to the words again, pay close attention um and then she says that if he doesn't agree to the Hitman being paid later, then I want the gun I paid for and I'm going to find someone else to do it. :7 p.m. 4 16:17 the same day, so it's still Monday, Hitman calls telling Mr.

Leo that he is 30 minutes away at 5:24 p.m. Mr. Bito directs The Hitman to the meeting place. She tells him I'm meeting him at CVS and Congress at Gateway. Mr. Shah is actually with her. She talks on the phone. She talks to Hitman a bit and they describe which cars. They were going to drive, I think the hitman was in a red Sebring and the man shot told them that they were driving in a gold Tahoe and you will see that the defendant was driving a gold Taho, he was a passenger in that car, so he says.

He puts her back on the phone and she gets back on the phone. He says, Hey, I know you're with your friend, but when we meet and talk about this, it means no one else knows. She says, but he, Mr. Ch, is in the parking lot. his car as they get into the car they talk so little before 6:00 p.m. he arrives at that place, she gets into his car, his car is recorded, so the second, his car is recorded just like Mr. Shah was recorded on Saturday, she gets into his car, they discuss the details of the murder , him and it's 20 something minutes.

Pay close attention to what she says, to her intention, to her confidence that this has to be done. I am absolutely sure that I want this guy K to hear her words and she wants it done soon. I want it done by Wednesday. Remember it's Monday. She mentions hey, you could kill him in the bank. He will be at the Bank of America in F. He will take 10,000 hits to kill him. There you can have 10,000 plus this, they discuss prices and things he accepts. the money after the fact um the police are listening live to all this stuff so they're they're they can listen so while the videos are playing or the phone calls are playing they're sitting next to it. to the person making the phone call or are listening live as will happen on Tuesday.

Mr. Jean contacts her, the Hitman, and he tells her that the bank thing is not going to work too risky, it is public, there is no way that is going to work or they "You have to do it with your house and she had already described her house her husband's bosses the fact that he just had surgery he doesn't have a gun the alarm situation what time he walks the dogs in the morning um, so okay, so" We'll do it in the morning , we will do it on Wednesday morning. You have to be home at 6:00 a.m. m. when you return home he will be dead, break the window of the house and make it look like he.

It was August 5, 2009, the day of the attack, the police are watching her house in the morning and of course a little 530 in the morning, guess who is leaving, she is going to work out at the gym so that her husband can get into the head and be killed inside. own house and that's the case we're asking you guys listen to all the evidence okay thank you Mr. Williams Mr. Claypool when you're ready tomorrow ladies and gentlemen remember yesterday we talked about actions speak more than words. This is a case about a corrupt Police Department the Boon Beach Police Department this department was more determined to generate an episode of Cops TV he forgot to tell you about that cop TV show he was on the Boon Beach Police Department he wanted filming at the police department and starting in July In July 2009, the director of communications for the Boon Beach Police Department, you will hear from Stephanie Slater, she will come in and tell you that she is circulating an email to the entire police department.

Hey, the cop TV show will be filming at the facility and you I'm going to hear testimony in this case that the first phone call Mr. Shahadi remembers, the first phone call he made to the Pointon Beach Police Department, he says : I don't think it's that serious, there's a domestic abuse problem and everything I want. What the Boon Beach Police Department needs to do is pick up the phone and call Dalia Say it, that's what he wanted them to do and he also said you're going to hear from him, we'll call him in this case, you'll hear his words .

He will tell you that he never thought this was serious. He will tell you that he never thought Misso would be arrested. Mr. Shahadi will tell you that he will look you in the eyes and tell you that he never wanted to get involved in any investigation. Mr. shahadi will tell you that he never wanted them to call him. Mr. Shah will tell you that he told the police department that he did not want to participate at all. Mr. shahadi will tell you that this is a confidential informant package that he signed and that the state is going to present to him they never explained to him what it was he didn't really understand what it was and in fact he is going to tell you that this Police Department misled him that They lied to him that they told him that you are going to remain confidential nothing is going to happen.

If this happens, you don't have to get involved and all you have to do is take a pen and sign here, that's what you're going to hear him talk to you about, so the evidence in this case will show that the conduct, pay attention as Mr. Williams told you, pay attention to his words, you must pay attention in this case to the conduct of the Boon Beach Police Department because that will tell you the truth, in this case is the conduct of this Police Department from the first day they never conducted a credible investigation in this case this was not an investigation the evidence will show in this case this supposed investigation had zero zero Integrity none and you are going to hear from a witness in this case Tim Williams 30 years of experience as a senior detective handling these types of investigations and he will tell you clearly that this investigation, this supposed investigation should be over, should be over by the time Muhammad shahadi tells the Department of Police I don't want to get involved and If you want to know why it should have ended, then I'll read it to you instead of reading it.

In this case you will hear what are called directives. Directives are policies and procedures generated by police departments. They are basically rules that a police department has to follow when conducting an undercover investigation one of those rules in this case and says point blank, I'm going to read it to you during the case, he says when an informant tells a police officer . to the Buon Beach police that I do not want to get involved in an investigation. I don't want to be telegraphed. I don't want to participate. The rule says the TW Beach Police Department must remove that report from the investigation.

They're done right there, but you want to know what happened. The HPD saw a great opportunity to appear on television. They wanted notoriety and fame. So what did they do when Mr. Shoty makes this first phone call? This guy calls and it's not a 911 call. It's an emergency call. Do you know what they tell them? You have to come to the police station. You know Mr. Shah says: I don't want to enter the police station. Do you know what they say to him? You have to come to the police station. so he goes to the police station and then you know what the police department tells him, then you have to cooperate and guess what they tell him after the old police department that is supposed to protect and hand over the evidence in this case will prove that this Police Department was deceiving and manipulating from their own fame and notoriety, you know what they told him, so you have to participate, well guess what we are going to prosecute you, you will hear Shahadi walk into this courtroom and he will tell you the next. words, three words, he was afraid, okay, he was afraid that this rogue police department would arrest him and prosecute him if he didn't follow the program, okay, let's talk about when shahadi shows up at the police station on July 31st as The Mr.

Williams told him that he then shows up at the police station and guess what these officers do. They remember that they want to stop a murder. You heard the talk about this. Oh, the evidence will show. Listen to Leo's words. She is going to murder. this guy guess what shahai shows up the police officers break the rules again they need to audio record the interview between the informant he wasn't informing him Shah calls he comes in they are supposed to interview him and record him well guess what guess what do they do? They spoke with Shahadi for more than two hours.

Yes. You may be wondering: are you going to listen to that interview? Guess what? No they will not. They are not going to listen to that interview because the Boon Beach Police Department did not bother to record those first two or three hours that they met with Mr. Sh and the evidence will show that the reason they did not interview him is because they They were laughing about it. There is evidence in this case that these officers We were laughing when Mr. Shahadi was describing what was going on. Does this sound like a police department is worried about Ms.

DPO putting a gun to Mike Dio's head? It doesn't seem that way to me andEvidence is going to show that they weren't worried that Miko was worried, they were laughing and the reason they didn't record that first 2-3 hour conversation is because they wanted to write a good cop TV show. They knew the cops were filming, so they said, holy shit. we're finding gold we get what we want This is great right this is going to be great they made more than what was there that's what this case is about so after that 2 to three hour interview in between they didn't record, then they recorded the conversation with Mr.

Shah and then they gave him, this confidential informant package they give him a package about 3 to 5 minutes thick, hey, sign, sign and then guess what, the same day they said we want you you call Dal Dio and by the way I say Dalia Dio, but guess what the evidence is. is going to show that this Police Department didn't even know her last name didn't even know her last name they were still they were hey Muhammad call her, let's try to schedule a meeting, let's schedule a meeting Listen to the evidence in this case from Tim Williams and even from his own people , Pointon Beach Police's own police officers, both current and former, will tell you that the conversations should have been recorded, should have been recorded and could have been recorded and were not and that we do not have those conversations and under Not having those conversations before us deeply compromises the integrity of the investigation, you have to have integrity in a Police Department investigation, whether you like someone or not, whether you think they said something bad or not, you can't break the rules and then being rewarded by breaking the rules and that's what this case is really about and then what happens going back to July 31st now they tell Shahadi to go call her.

Prepare something right, there will be testimony in this case and evidence that August 31st and then July 31st and August 1st look at it Shot only August 1st remember that's the day this Bo Beach P was speeding up the things and wants to go meet at a gas station, guess what 186 phone calls 186 phone calls made by Mohamed in a day before meeting her on mobile g at the gas station in Mobile, now what does that tell you in this case? If you think Daliao was determined to kill her husband, then why did Muhammad Shahadi have to call her 18,186 times for her to meet him?

That's common sense. You know it's you and you ask yourself this, ask yourself the rules. The police department demands that all those phone calls be recorded, they are supposed to be recorded because it preserves integrity, it creates credibility within the police investigation and what it does is eliminate any speculation about what was said or not said. and we don't have any of those zero audio recordings, that is an abuse of power, the evidence in this case is going to show that it is an absolute categorical abuse of power by the officers of the Pointon Beach Police Department, so we have the so we move on to the meeting at the Mobile gas station the interesting thing about this is that after that meeting remember Mr.

Williams said there was a little bit of a delay remember that meeting at the gas station that took place on August 1st the next tape that You see, it was thought that he didn't. I don't think so, and this undercover hitman was on August 3rd. Well, two days now, the evidence in this case will show that if the Buon Beach Police Department really believed that Doo intended to kill her husband, do you think they're going to wait? two days and I'm going to schedule another meeting at Pharmacy C. I think the testimony here in this case is that if a police department really believes that someone is going to kill someone, are they going to do something immediately to prevent that, well, what? guess what? on August 3rd when there is this meeting on CBS, they still don't know Dalia's last name, they don't even know where Mike Deo lives, they have done very little background research on Muhammad shahad and what they do on August 3rd is I have these meetings and no one from The Point Beach Police Department calls me, that's EV, shows you they didn't answer the phone, hey Mike, we think your wife is here, you better keep an eye out, get some security, give her security, do surveillance without surveillance.

It was all done until Deo, are you kidding me? Does that really sound like a police department that really believes that Dalia DPO is going to kill her husband? I have only told you about 186 phone calls on August 2, 2009 135 phone calls from Muhammad Shahab to die and guess what friends, in this case again, the rules are broken the moment we do not have access to those 135 because they are not they bothered to record and those telephone conversations and you are intelligent enough to know why they did not record that conversation any of those conversations of August 3, 2009 105 telephone calls that the shahadi is making to you do not think that this is pressure the evidence in This case is going to show that that multitude of unrecorded phone calls by a The individual who feels threatened with being prosecuted by the police department who is interested in fame and fortune on the television show Cops, that proves that he felt pressured and why she felt pressured to go through with this because the undercover, Shah's informant, had been told by the guy from the Bo Beach Police Department, we're going after you unless you do the job and I'm going to make you Shah understands that he will tell you that he was calling Detective Marino and saying: Hey Marina, can you? stop calling me yeah Shah will sit there and tell everyone he was getting tired of Detective Marino harassing him 10 times a day Muhammad did you get her Muhammad you called her Muhammad you set up the meeting and remember Tim Williams?

I told you about the 30-year veteran of the Los Angeles Police Department, he's going to come and tell you, you know, he's going to tell you that he's never, ever in his career seen an investigation, an undercover investigation that involved an attempt to kill someone that happens in the span of three days three or four days people tell you that this is unprecedented, that you can't speed things up so quickly by speeding up you break the rules and you compromise in this case the evidence in this case will show that it is not can reward a police department for bad behavior.

Now let's talk a little more about this, this gentleman named Sergeant Charity, okay, remember he has the CVS meeting on August 3rd, but before that there was this meeting between Daliao. and this gentleman with jeene that you will hear about there was a meeting just before Dalia went and met the ingenious Jean. Remember that Wy Jeene is the undercover police officer. Now Muhammad Shahai was the gentleman he called. It's what's called a confidential, so before Dalia leaves. and they meet Wy Jean at CBS, they have a meeting in a restaurant in Chile and guess who organized and met, it wasn't Delo, it was Muhammad Shahai, so ask yourself this question during the case, why is it like this, if Mr.

Williams is telling the truth and he can prove this, why if Dalia Dilo is so determined to kill her husband and she is so determined to do it, why does Shahadi have to meet her now at Chil's before he she go and meet the witty jeene big? Well, the evidence in this case is going to show that the reason Shahadi had to have this meeting at Chili's is because both he and Detective Marino knew they were losing Dalia Deo. We're going to have Marino here. I'm going to ask about that they knew they were losing her she was reluctant to move forward with this they were worried about the cops let's talk about cops real quick I didn't give you the timeline and I apologize for the months 7 weeks after the Boon Beach Police Department she he's sending emails, he's sending notes to the TV show Cops.

Hey guys, when you come here to film the right months, she's trying to push for you to come and commit to it. She sends an explosive email to everyone from the Boyon Beach police. I'll be here August 5th so if anyone from Bo comes here and tries to tell you otherwise they're lying because everyone in that Police Department knew cops were bu but guess what happens to share it again remember to speak up Sergeant Sheridan Sergeant. Sheridan was the leader, well he was the main supervisor, in this case Detective Marino was in the trenches. Sharon was good.

Sharon goes on the TV show Cops and says, "Hey, we're not going to cover patrol cars, we have a better one." story for you, that's what it does, it changes the programming of the Cops TV show so they can cover wow and in fact the Boon Beach Police Department circulated footage in this case, why is it such a big deal? The evidence will show that this proves that they had a motive, they had a motive to set up Dalo and fabricate her alleged CR, they had a clear motive. Fame, notoriety, by publishing all this information out of the world to still see it on your website.

Believe it or not, evidence will show that it sounds like a police department. That's really interested in stopping people from killing each other and guess what else Sharidan does. You're going to hear about it after they finally figure it out at the police station. You know how desperate this guy is. You know how desperate he is to drink. take a piece of paper, now she sits in front of the police station, who is in front of her, hey, hey, sign, sign this piece of paper, it's just a waiver of your Miranda Rights, you know, Miranda Rights already They are right to remain silent, so just sign.

Here it is, you're just waving your Miranda rights. The right wrist is bothered. Signs. The document is removed. He takes it to the guy. Mr. Langley on the TV show Cops. Mr. Langley looks at him and says, "Wait a minute. She, this was a waiver for Rands, he says, yeah, we know what the cops say, well, well, it's not a waiver of Miranda Rights, right, committed fraud, you know what she did, it was a waiver, that's how desperate this police department is. Department, it was a waiver for her to appear on the TV show Cops. Can you believe a sergeant in a police department committed fraud to try to show this on television?

That's how desperate this Police Department was to fabricate this alleged crime. Now, let me almost do it. Let me back up a little bit now let's go back to Chile remember we were talking about Chile Chile is important the evidence is going to show that again the reason why Mohammed shahadi has to organize that meeting is because he is losing Val di losing and he is worried right now this guy is worried if I can't record it with a covert drink he might go to jail he will tell you no do you think he has something personal at stake in this case he now has a motive you have a motive by the police department right to fabricate this he now has a motive in this case by Mohammed shahadi to set up valyo to instigate press you tell me more than five will hear evidence more than 570 phone calls over a 5 day period, I broke down some of the days where it was 570 phone calls and if this was a fair trial with a level playing field by a police department Guess what you guys would be listening to, 575 audio recordings so we could get to the truth so we could find out if Dio was actually reluctant, if she was worried about this, maybe she needed to reconsider this, maybe she had issues with her husband that They needed to be resolved, but guess what, we won't have those audio tapes. because a police department is so reckless, Hess, selfish and self-centered that they intentionally made sure her script for the TV show Cops moved forward at the expense of trashing Dalia Dio's constitutional rights, that's what this case is about, don't fall for it . of this TR now in Chile just to prove my point I will finally take you to Chile The Shah will enter here his honor will take an oath to the Shah you already know what he is going to say I swear to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth and guess what guys im 100% sure you cabled me when i came into chice 100% was asked numerous times in depositions well guess what when everyone wants to hear what happened in that 40 minute encounter at J just right before coincidentally just before he takes her in a car to the clever Jean, who is sitting right here, he takes her there, why is he taking her there?

He wants to make sure she delivers what he needs to deliver. keep going so you don't get upset so you don't get prosecuted, you're going to hell, well we don't have that, it doesn't exist, that's a blatant violation of the Design Beach Police Department's policies and procedures, they're called directives, it's good. Not only did we hear from our expert in this case, Tim Williams, but you'll also hear from Frank Ramsey. Frank Ramsey is a former sergeant from the beginning and will tell you that this is totally inappropriate police misconduct and that he should have an audio recording. that chill 40 minutes here's another thing I forgot to say.

The Beach Police Department is so excited about the police episode that they have about 13. Maybe you can here here here here here here here heard about the police officers surrounding Chili's right and How about thisnot a single point and the Beach police officer enters CH? Why do you think it is important? This Tru Police Department denied having monitored at least one of the two subordinates within the list that everyone knew this was all bullshit, this was all a script that they We all knew this wasn't serious so they don't send no one inside. Now let's talk about that Mr.

Shah saying that he was well connected. You will hear testimony from, possibly, Sergeant Sheridan, but you will hear from Mr. Bonair a couple of times. other people at the dpd point guess what they said happened right they are going to try to come here and tell you that oh we believe the cable malfunction can you believe this woman is going to kill her husband and there is a yo ? going to You will be here in this casethere is a policy and procedure in place. Agree with the Police Department saying this: you can't, you can't, you can't, you can't, you can't compromise an investigation, no, no, if there's an equipment malfunction, you can't, so what does that mean? ?, they broke the rule again.

What that means is and Sergeant Ramsey is going to be honest with you, we don't know this guy, he's going to tell the former sergeant 20 years on the police force, former BPD sergeant, he's going to tell you straight up that there's no excuse for moham if he really there was a malfunction CH There is no excuse for our position in this case and the others will show that we believe Mr Sh was connected and there was no function just to make it clear that the evidence on our part will suggest he was connected. They have the audio. and for some reason we don't have that audio, let me tell you why real quick, let me fast a little, here's why, because you're going to hear from the people in the city too, we sent them a request and said.

Hello, send us all your information about video cabling equipment repairs. Send us all your information to request new wiring. Guess what we got. Zero. There is no record. There is no record of the Boon Beach Police Department ordering any new wiring equipment or receiving any wiring. equipment repaired what does that tell you the evidence in this case will tell you that they are lying they are lying again they are cheating and they are destroying evidence that is what we are going to argue we are going to prove it why Are they doing that because they don't want anyone to know that Miss Diolo is backing out because they don't want anyone to know because that's going to kill their script?

There is a once in a lifetime opportunity to become famous after it all goes on TV. that will kill him, we have to make sure that doesn't happen, the interesting thing is I will tell you that from today we don't even need to know who telegraphed Muhammad Shahai, we don't even know who, who from the police department telegraphed him. Where did what happened with the wiring happen? I haven't heard of Peep yet. I hope the state talks about that. Do we know what really went wrong? What is the evidence for that? Is there any evidence of that?

We argued that no, there is no evidence in this case of malfunction and that means that this Police Department allowed a man who had a checkered history in the past without going into details to walk into a restaurant with someone he was supposed to kill. to her husband 10 minutes before she went and met undercover agent C. and in this case we have no idea what those students did, but I'm going to tell you that the evidence in this case will show that at that moment Dal Deo was reluctant to do this and Muhammad shahadi was pressuring her and what more evidence do you need in this case than 576 phone calls, all of you are smart enough, you know that if this woman wanted to kill her husband and she is so sure that he's going to do it, you know how many phone calls he would make.

I took a phone call from Shah to the DPO, but it took 576 phone calls to finish this script for the TV show Cops, so at the end of the day we will ask him not to find us and the reason why we are there. I will ask you to find it not because of the conduct, the egregious misconduct, the flagrant violations of the law and policies and procedures within the Police, the categorical and massive failure to preserve the evidence that we need in this case to get to the conclusion. truth and the way they control the evidence, everyone knows we talk about this at Juris, the evidence will show that the police department has the upper hand in investigations, they control everything they believe is a fair planning field that we hear about in this The argument of the case is evident, it was not like that, they controlled all the mechanisms to preserve an investigation full of integrity to carry out their honorable work and the evidence of this case will show that they completely destroyed, completely mocked the authorities in all of this, a mockery of our law enforcement system by putting their own interest above Miss Nio violating her constitutional rights through the egregious misconduct of this police department and at the end of the day what are we going to do? ask me to do is declare Mr.

Le innocent because look no further, look no further, actions speak louder than words, remember that through Ro's case, watch the video is all you want, but watch the litany, connect the dots, remember to connect those dots from shahai's first phone call to the press. pressure intimidation prosecution 576 phone calls no audio recordings no audio recordings of chili Sergeant Sher committing fraud connect all those dots and at the end of this case you will discover that it is the misconduct of this Police Department that will show you that this woman hence, Mis Valu, never intended to kill. Thank you very much for her time this morning.

I look forward to speaking with you again on the case. Thank you, Mr. Claypool, thank you, your honor. Status ready to call as first witness. I want to speak well, uh counselor, can you come closer for just a second? e e e e e e