Amanuel-TX | Why God Won't Let Us See Him | Atheist Experience 26.46

right, sorry, and I think you hit the nail on the head when you use oral slaves, and that's exactly the same argument, people you know, exactly the same. The market people were made in the days of slavery. I am yours, I can. Do what I want, I will bread you with these other two slaves. I made this baby on purpose and therefore I can decide what happens to you. That's not a good argument, it doesn't mean it's morally right, yeah, I'm not saying it's a good thing, uh, what I was saying is that he has the potential, if he really exists, we understand what you're saying, keep dancing around a central theme and that is why you worship a capricious God who does not obey His own rules, who does things apparently for fun because he wants to, we would consider that evil and we cannot, and because he does it, he sins, no We can trust His judgment to be fair, accurate, or correct, so why worship?

Yes, but by the way. I didn't say God is evil because that's like blasphemy and that's like that's not an answer to the question, that's a problem, that's what I'm sorry, continue answering Jim's question, I'll talk about that later, it's well, what's the question? I didn't understand the Ask yourself why worship a god who is willing to violate your free will and who acts like a bad father on multiple occasions and you can because he does all these things, you can't trust him to judge you fairly, yeah, why worship that? Because I just told you someone. he had a gun even though I don't want to submit, I will submit because he has power and that's it, all you have here, the whole religion is, please don't hurt me, I will.

Whatever you say there is no love there is no generosity there is no forgiveness there is nothing it's just please don't hurt me no but there are people I wouldn't say that 100 because there are people who do things out of love and there are people who do things out of fear, no of God God does everything out of fear apparently eh no no because God does things because he has the power to not start to deny that we are saying why that? Why does that Garner love it if someone points a gun at him? He says and worship me or die you are going to worship that person no, I am not going to worship that person but you are going to worship God he says the same thing yes but I wouldn't worship him because I don't I want to go to jail, okay, we just said worship me or something bad will happen to you, that's what we just said and you said you wouldn't worship a human who did that, but you would worship a God who does that and who says there is a The difference, I understand, the difference is that you know hell is supposed to be Eternal and you know it's Immortal, if you die here on Earth who cares if you go to heaven and as I understand well the question is what do I really want to drive.

Here at home, what you keep constantly saying is that you are only worshiping this God out of fear of retaliation, if you don't, your fear of this God punishing you is the reason you worship him. Now, obviously, Jim and I don't believe this. God is real in the first place, that's the point of this whole show. We don't believe this is real, but the question is not: is he real? The question is: aren't we going to worship him? The question I have is. Is it a good thing to do? Would you take that away from anyone else if the United States government came and said we got a bunch of new stuff?

Then you will give us all the resources you have. That's the moral if I come to you. and have a gun and say you're going to adore and love me, it doesn't matter if you would, is it okay for me to do it, is it acceptable? I know you don't want to say God is bad, but I just hope. that in your head you can understand it for a second what you are telling us is that they are bullying you into submission they are threatening you into behavior that is not good that is not a loving God that is not moral that is not nice that is not beautiful, wonderful, perfect, anything, it doesn't matter if someone might hurt you, the fact that you know they will, terrifies you so much by walking away from them that you don't want to hurt their feelings, you don't even want to say anything. negative against them that's abuse that's torture that's wrong do you understand that yes, yes I get it, what you just said makes a lot of sense, wow, so God is evil, well why wouldn't I say that it's because I don't want to because for everything I say I think I will be judged, so I wouldn't say, I would say, I would just say God is good, you know what I'm saying, so real quick, real quick, because I understand what you're saying.

Saying Emmanuel, I really do well. I'm not trying to put you down here. I really understand if you say that's something blasphemous and you think you'll be punished for it, real quick, even if it's just magical. Fantasyland, okay, imagine I have it all. The same powers as your God. I am exactly the same in every way. I can do all the things that your God can do and in fact I have. I have my own universe with my own things and I have no control over you. Well, I'm exactly the same. What is your God and I can't hurt you at all, would you say I'm evil?

No, I wouldn't say that because you have that power to do whatever you want except for yourself. I can't touch you at all. That's the magic of the stage I can do whatever I want I have all the power in the world except I can't hear you Oh if you can't touch me I wouldn't submit to you So the only thing between us and God is a judgment That's the difference , so I just want to be clear, I can't touch you, I can't hurt you, would you say I was evil if I did the exact same things, yes, yes, I would say?

You're, you're a very evil person, great, yeah, that's it, that's it, man, and I mean this sincerely, I truly, I sincerely hope that you think critically about your beliefs because we don't believe that your God is real, we don't believe that you. I have a reason to be afraid. I understand that you are afraid of this guy. I don't think this guy is real, but what I think is really important for you to understand and for everyone watching to understand is that if it were anyone else, if you took the fear of punishment it goes away even you might admit that everything what he says is simply evil he is monstrous no no but but but he says that you will be judged if you really say right that I understand that I understand that I am not saying that you said Yes, yes, okay anyway, thank you very much for calling Emanuel, we will move on to the next call yeah ok thanks take care man super important call there yeah I agree and it's very important.

I really hope more theists hear that specifically because I hope a lot of people deal with that, you know, I can't say God is bad because he'll punish me, but if someone else who couldn't punish me did the exact same things, I wouldn't do it. problem absolutely saying that's bad but it's good from God I love you that's great yes what you are seeing is a fear response you are seeing someone who is being tortured and harmed and abused to be nice to an abuser . I hope everyone learned something from that. thank you Emmanuel for being an example for the class I sincerely hope you like it think about that seriously because holy shit I feel bad for that guy yes really