YTread Logo
YTread Logo

Are the castles in Game of Thrones realistic?

Jun 06, 2021
ratings I'm Shad and the TV show Game of Thrones has a lot of things that are

realistic

in a medieval sense. That said, though there are also a lot of things that Game of Thrones gets wrong, but in the broader scheme of things in all kinds of medieval. The fantasy seas that have been made into Game of Thrones are much more accurate than many other TV shows and movies based on a medieval period or theme and, with that in mind, let's take a look and see how accurate the fantasy seas are.

castles

in the

game

of In the television series of Thrones now we will not take a look at all the

castles

that appear in the television series, but what we will do is take a look at some of the most prominent, common or important castles that appear in the program.
are the castles in game of thrones realistic
I will be looking at how the TV series depicts or describes these castles because I am aware that many of these castles are described differently in the books compared to how they are depicted in the TV show, so this is not a look at the castles. castles. as described in the books, is specifically a look at how they are shown and portrayed in the television show. Now the difficulty in doing this is that there are very few detailed shots of the castles in the show due to budget constraints, most of them when they show the castle are very wide shots and there are no wide scenes showing the castles and all their splendor from all angles.
are the castles in game of thrones realistic

More Interesting Facts About,

are the castles in game of thrones realistic...

It's usually a static image showing the castle from a single angle, but I'll do my best from a few. From the more detailed images I've been to find all these castles and we'll start with Winterfell now from this angle Winterfell looks very, very believable and when I say that what I mean is that every structure that I see I can see that too. structure being built in a historic setting, nothing is so monolithically large that it would have made it impractical or impossible to build it with medieval technology and I also can't see anything that defies the laws of architecture or physics, so from these perspectives it is Very believable, some of the things that stand out to me when I look at this castle is the use of fences around some of the hours and also other structures, so the fences or fences are the wooden battlements that are fixed to the outside of some of the The towers, which is very historically accurate, will place castles to give bows and defenders a platform to shoot at their enemies and will also provide protection from incoming arrow fire.
are the castles in game of thrones realistic
It should be noted that a little later in the design of the castle fences were placed. architectural ii combined with towers and castle walls like z' registration and the regular battlements, so when that happened, the fences were not really necessary now, when we look at Winterfell, we don't actually see any of the battlement or the battlement that we are extended. from the side or top of the walls, which would mean billboards, would be the option to go with, which also identifies the architectural style of Winterfell as being a bit older in the medieval period and, from what I understand, of the law of

game

of

thrones

, it makes sense, what I don't see are battlements along the exterior or the outer wall and that is very strange, it is a defensive weakness of this castle, the other strange thing that catches my attention when I look This castle in In an objective and analytical sense, it is the roofs of these towers and in some of the cases of other building structures, the roofs of the towers are the ones that particularly stand out to me and the thing about them is that they are so flat.
are the castles in game of thrones realistic
I know castles in other cultures, not really medieval based cultures, but in other cultures where they have flat roofs. Now this is a fantasy, so of course this style can be incorporated into this castle without any problems. What problem would actually exist is a question. of functionality is fine, what is the main theme of House Stark? What are your words? Winter is coming and therefore, of anyone in Game of Thrones everything, in the world of Game of Thrones it should be the Starks and the people of Winterfell who should really understand that concept: winter is coming and causing changes in many things, one of them is snow, when winter comes you have to deal with a lot of snow and of course this is called a winter offender so it has to be built to be outside. a management of winter and snow and these flat roofs are a complete contradiction with that logic that you see when there is a lot of snow, it accumulates and if you have a flat roof it will also accumulate on the roof and many times that weight will be so great that the roof It won't be able to support it and it will collapse, so you will find everywhere in a medieval period when snow was common, the roofs were tilted at a very steep angle and this was so that the snow would slide off. the edges, so these roofs of the Towers must have very pointed and pronounced angles, they must not be flat, it is not a problem in the summer and you know that summers last quite a long time, but so do winters, unless Sean I'm going to replace all the roofs when winter finally comes, which seems like it's taking forever, but when it finally comes, these roofs are not built to withstand winter weather at all, so there you have it.
Thoughts on Winterfell Castle, let's move on to the red tower. Now let's review all the castles I have seen in the Game of Thrones series. The red tower is the one that seems most similar to the design of a fantasy castle to me. Don't get me wrong, what I mean when I say that the red keep catches my attention is one of the strongest fantasy designs in terms of its silhouette, its size and also some of the architecture it contains. I am well aware that there are some castles in Game of Thrones that look very fantastic, especially when it comes to their location, such as Pike Castle and Eyrie, but don't worry, I will explain what I mean when I say that the red tower It attracts attention, it is one of the strongest fantasies.
The designs have to do with its silhouette in size and also with part of the architecture that is in it, such as this extended part that looks at the city from the red keep, which is a strongly Gothic style architecture that was never used traditionally in royal historic castles where it is found. Many influences of the Gothic style regarding castles are the fantastical interpretation of castles like Disney Castle etc., which is why the red tower actually has a fantasy feel to it, especially with how tall it is and how everything becomes taller. high as you move towards the central part of the castle.
Now, regarding the other architectural styles of the red tower, that seems very authentic and

realistic

to me. You see some very effective battlements there and you also see some realistic looking towers. What makes this castle a little less realistic is its sheer size, it is very, very tall. There are some historic castles that could be compared in size to the size of the red key, but those are rarer exceptions than what occurs in the common historic. The castle was, but even they would find it difficult to become as high and tall as the Red Keep appears to be when it comes to the design of the outer walls, which are actually some very good defenses.
What they have there has to lower Bailey's level. or barriers extending behind additional walls from the main inner Bailey, each with a fortified entrance gate that would make storming this castle very, very difficult and all other access points from the main entrance are a cliff surrounded by the ocean. This castle is very, very fortified and defensible. I really like that because even with some of the fantasy elements put into its design, especially that cathedral gothic style part on the front, it is still made to be very practical and this style is actually one of my favorite fantasy styles . designs I don't mind, you know, some unrealistic and fantasy style embellishments, especially in the size and the big jar, as long as we keep it based on realism, practicality and function, and the red tower really calls me attention in that sense, that this is what they have.
Okay, there you have it, that's the red tower, now let's move on to Castle Pike, the fortress and seat of House Greyjoy, now aside from the correct location, Pike strikes me as one of the most historically authentic castle designs in Game of Thrones. Thrones, now it's interesting. You could think of Pike as four different types of castles, but they are grouped together and each one leads to and from the other and I'm sorry, it's considered that you know this is a castle together, but with each of these individuals, you know, the The bodies of the castles are very very historically authentic, they are clearly inspired by some of the earlier castle designs, specifically the Norman keep style castles, which were much more square and blocky than rounded.
Also, the battlements at the top do not extend outwards from the wall and, again, these are the style of battlements that are very common to have fences fixed in times of war, but the battlements are there, as well as individual towers. What is also extremely authentic about this castle is the lack of windows on the outside, there are barely any that you can really see. mostly loopholes and maybe one or two windows on the upper levels, which is very, very accurate because windows are a big weakness in royal castles now because of their location and from a cursory glance could be considered that structures built on sea stacks like This would be extremely unlikely, well actually, yes and no, you see, there are some legitimate historic structures that are built in unlikely places almost almost because the big deciding factor for a Pike Castle is that it is in the sea or on the seashore, if so.
On the seashore would be much more plausible because there are some real historical structures in the world that are built on very comparable rock formations, but not on the sea like the Meteora monasteries, just take a look at some of the rocks. formations on which these monasteries are built, the difference is that these rock formations are under much less danger of erosion than if they were in the sea. You see a sea stack, which is what several of the Castle Pike castle structures are built on. marine erosion and once they are formed they don't last forever and their stability is also questionable now if they were very stable and strong and how many hundreds of years for erosion to completely remove the BAPS II stack then it might be plausible to you. build a structure on top of it, but it wouldn't last forever and I think that's what they're implying with the castle pike is also that these sea stacks are slowly eroding them so this castle won't stay intact. for much longer, but for the time it would remain there, it is incredibly defensible, oh my goodness, the other towers behind the first main body of the castle would be basically impenetrable, you couldn't get them from anywhere else with an army large enough to reach it and the castle as a whole looks impressive.
This is a beautiful castle for its medieval authenticity and also for the novelty of its unique location, which is not as unreal as it might seem, it is not practical, don't get me wrong. There's a much better chance of those sea stacks being unstable than stable, but if they were stable then you could get away with it, it definitely wouldn't last forever, a lot of what we've talked about about Castle Pike regarding its location is also can apply to the Eyrie, the difference is that the Eyrie is not on the seashore, which means that if its rock base is stable enough, this structure could feasibly be built, in reality it would be incredibly difficult and what they would have needy.
The first thing they need to do is build an access to the top of this rock formation, so they would have had to build that long, winding road first, but we've built comparable roads and walls like that in history, think of the Great Wall and the mountains where that thing hides. Once you have access to the top of this rock formation, you will need to lift each stone one at a time to build the structure and if the foundation was stable enough you could get away with it because there are some historical comparisons. What can we do, of course, the real life historical ones don't have anything as grand as the Eyrie built on top of them, but they are built in an incomparably difficult location with respect to architectural style, it is very difficult.
I had a hard time finding one nearby. General images of the area itself are just wide angle shots, but from the looks of it, it appears to be a highly vaulted structure with vaulted ceilings and not really a castle, more of a cathedral or palace. I really don't see many. there is a battle in it and you know that in reality if this were real you wouldn't need many on the battlements, it is so high up, it is so good and it is so difficult to get to you that its mere location is enough defense and the main part you would need to defend is that wall winding and the path that leads tohe.
You put enough gates along the way on that path and you could hold an army of almost unlimited size because there is only one access point to get to this castle and without inventing airplanes. There's really no way you can try to take this structure, other than a long-term siege to starve them, as presented in the TV series. From the angle and perspective we have in this shot, the Eyrie would be incredibly large, absolutely enormous. much larger than a castle would have been in history, but the Eyrie is not really a castle, as I said before, it is more of a large palace with a dome and a cathedral than a castle and historically we have palaces of incredible size.
That should be remembered, although it would be feasible to build a structure like this in real life, it would be incredibly impractical and incredibly difficult, to the point that I don't think anyone would do it in real life, but that's just my opinion, it might be wrong here and finally, let's take a look at Dragonstone now, of all the castles we've seen so far. Dragonstone is by far an uncomplicated militaristic fortress, it doesn't care about looking fancy or ornate, it's simply here to do a job now, of course, due to its size and imposing appearance, it looks grand and impressive, there's just no no ornaments to adorn it.
What's also interesting about this castle, it actually has some pretty advanced defensive designs, specifically with those kind of spikes sticking out. Now there are parts on the wall, that type of design is something you can find more in a star fort than in an actual medieval castle. Now a star fort or bastion fort is a fortress that emerged after the medieval period and was a style that evolved. During the age of gunpowder, when cannons came to dominate the battlefield, now the purpose of these sharp parts protruding from the wall was to deflect fire from the cannons.
Now, of course, cannons don't exist in Westeros yet, so the question arises as to why. This design philosophy was adopted in Dragonstone unlike other castles, but even without cannon fire, these extended parts of the wall serve a very functional purpose: it gives the defenders on the wall a greater ability to fire at enemies. What you will notice about the battlements. on the edge of Dragonstone is that they have license plate Defenders on the wall can shoot arrows or throw stones at anyone who tries to storm the walls, what I mean is that it's kind of superfluous because I don't see anyone even approaching the walls because Dragonstone is located on a cliff in the sea, but Hey , why not?
It's just that you know that greater security gives them peace of mind and then we get to the size and as I measure how big Dragonstone appears to be compared to other medieval castles, I get the impression that Dragon Stone is easily larger than any historic castle ever built that's not a criticism because again this is a fantasy they can get away with. It is important to note so that people don't get confused that the historic castles were not that big and there you have it, these are my thoughts on the castles in the television series Game of Thrones I hope you enjoyed them if you want to learn more about the differences between classic fantasy castle and historical castles please go watch my video fantasy castle vs reality and until then goodbye if you want Support Shadow Versity or express your appreciation for a video you particularly liked.
Become a patron through Patreon. Your one dollar donation would be absolutely wonderful.

If you have any copyright issue, please Contact